Station controller design: Pi vs Pico/ESP32 for CAT, rotator, antenna switch and SWR, and keeping RF out of it
- Replies 2
- Views 52
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
Planning a small station automation setup and trying to decide how to split the work between a Raspberry Pi and microcontrollers. The wish list is CAT control for a rig, a rotator controller with position feedback, a remote antenna switch, a forward/reflected power readout for SWR, and eventually a Direwolf APRS node on the same network.
The obvious approach is a Pi running Hamlib (rigctld and rotctld) plus logging and Direwolf, with a Pico or ESP32 handling anything that needs hard real-time behavior or direct I/O: relay drivers, ADC readings and display updates. The open questions are where that boundary should sit and what causes trouble once real RF is in the room.
Specific points to discuss:
1. CAT interfaces differ a lot. Icom CI-V is a single-wire bus, many Yaesu radios use TTL-level serial or USB, and some Kenwoods use true RS-232 levels. What is a sane way to interface these to 3.3 V logic without frying a GPIO?
2. ADC accuracy for rotator potentiometer feedback and SWR detector voltages. Is the internal ADC on the ESP32 or Pico good enough, or is an external ADC the better choice?
3. Relay and antenna switch drivers: how much isolation is worth adding, and where should the switching hardware live relative to the feedline and the controller?
4. What are the realistic failure modes when the controller sits a few meters from an antenna on 100 W of HF, and how do you design against them from the start?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10770-station-controller-design-pi-vs-picoesp32-for-cat-rotator-antenna-switch-and-swr-and-keeping-rf-out-of-it/Share on other sites