Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75 (and where the IC-705 fits), plus CHIRP, offsets and emergency setup
- Replies 2
- Views 52
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This is a discussion starter for anyone choosing a first or second handheld. The usual shortlist is a budget Baofeng, the Yaesu FT-65R, Icom's ID-52A, Kenwood's TH-D75, and sometimes the IC-705, even though that last one isn't really an HT. Here is how I'd break down the tradeoffs.
Analog dual-band: Baofeng and FT-65R. Both cover 2 m and 70 cm FM at about 5 W, which is all most people need for local repeaters and simplex. The FT-65R is a simple, rugged analog radio with a conventional keypad and no digital modes or GPS. Budget Baofengs cost much less and CHIRP supports them well. The usual criticism is that receiver selectivity and transmitter filtering are weaker than on name-brand radios. That matters if you live near strong commercial or public-safety transmitters, or if you care about clean spurious and harmonic suppression. For a first radio to learn repeater operation, either one works. If you want something you won't outgrow, a name-brand radio gives you better support and a more predictable menu.
D-STAR: ID-52A and TH-D75. The ID-52A is a dual-band D-STAR handheld with GPS and Bluetooth, and it can receive two signals at once. The TH-D75 is Kenwood's tri-band (2 m, 1.25 m, 70 cm) handheld with D-STAR, built-in GPS and APRS. D-STAR is only useful if you have local D-STAR repeaters or hotspot access, and you need to register your callsign with the D-STAR network before using gateway features. Both radios also work as ordinary FM radios, so the digital side is optional.
DMR. Neither of those radios does DMR, so if DMR is the goal you need a different handheld. DMR setup is more involved than analog. You need a DMR ID, a codeplug with the right color codes, time slots and talkgroups, and the repeater operator's requirements. If you're curious, find out what DMR coverage you actually have before buying.
IC-705. This is a portable HF/VHF/UHF transceiver with D-STAR, not a pocket HT. It makes sense if you want SSB and CW on HF, or a portable station. It isn't what you'd clip to your belt. Compare it against an HT only if HF portable is part of your plan.
Batteries. Rated capacity is only part of it. Buy a spare pack, and consider a battery case that takes AA cells if your model offers one, since AAs are easy to find in an emergency. Charge cradles and USB charging are convenient but vary by model. Li-ion packs lose capacity over time, so rotate and test them rather than assuming a pack from a drawer will last.
Antennas. The stock rubber duck is a compromise. A better aftermarket whip, or a roll-up J-pole for use indoors or in the field, often improves range more than extra wattage does. Check the connector first: most of these radios use an SMA-female jack on the radio, but verify for your exact model before ordering, because SMA-male and SMA-female antennas aren't interchangeable. Also beware of counterfeit antennas, since plenty of imitations are sold under popular brand names.
Programming with CHIRP. CHIRP is free and handy for managing memory channels and importing repeater lists. The routine is the same every time: download from the radio first and save that image as a backup, make your edits, then upload. Check CHIRP's supported-radio list before assuming your model works, because support varies and some newer radios may not be included. Cheap programming cables with counterfeit USB chips can cause driver headaches. A name-brand cable or a known-good chipset saves time.
Repeater offsets. In the US, 2 m repeaters typically use a 600 kHz offset, with the direction depending on the part of the band. As a general guide, output frequencies from 146.610 to 146.970 and from 147.600 to 147.990 use a negative offset, while 146.000 to 146.390 and 147.000 to 147.390 use a positive one. On 70 cm the offset is typically 5 MHz, either direction depending on the sub-band and local coordination. Other regions use different offsets, so check your local band plan. You may also need a CTCSS (PL) tone for the repeater. If you can hear the repeater but it never responds, the tone is the first thing to check.
Emergency use. A radio is only useful if you already know how to run it. Program your local repeaters, a few simplex channels (146.520 is the national 2 m calling frequency in the US), the NOAA weather channels if your radio receives them, and any local ARES or net frequencies. Practice with the menus before you need them, keep a printed channel list, and carry spare batteries. Don't count on repeaters during a major outage, since they can lose power or be overloaded, so simplex capability matters. And only transmit within the privileges of your license.
What are you trying to do: local repeaters, digital modes, APRS, or emergency prep? And which of these would you pick for a beginner?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10795-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-fits-plus-chirp-offsets-and-emergency-setup/Share on other sites