Gain, dynamic range and antennas: why does the same SDR look fine on one band and overloaded on another?
- Replies 2
- Views 39
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
This is a technical discussion starter for anyone using an RTL-SDR, HackRF, SDRplay, Airspy or LimeSDR. A common pattern: an SDR looks clean on 2 m or the airband, then the FM broadcast band, a local pager transmitter or a nearby ham station produces ghost signals, a lifted noise floor or "birdies" that move when you change gain. The waterfall looks busy, but not all of it is real.
The first thing to separate is the noise floor you see from the noise floor you have. The ADC resolution matters (an RTL-SDR uses an 8-bit converter, the HackRF One also 8 bits, while SDRplay, Airspy R2 and LimeSDR use 12-bit class converters), but so does where the gain sits. A wideband front end sees everything inside its tuner range, not just the slice you are displaying. A strong FM broadcast signal can overload the tuner or ADC even if you are watching 145 MHz at 2 MHz bandwidth.
The second thing is that the display lies a little. The FFT size and resolution bandwidth change the apparent noise floor, since narrower bins show a lower floor per bin. Comparing SDR# at one FFT setting with SDRuno or GQRX at another is not a fair test of receiver sensitivity unless you account for bin width.
A few questions to get the discussion going:
1. How do you set gain in practice? Maximum gain, AGC, or a manual method based on the band and antenna?
2. When do you reach for a notch or bandpass filter (FM bandstop, airband filter, 1090 MHz filter, HF low-pass) instead of changing receivers?
3. For HF, do you prefer direct sampling, an upconverter, or a dedicated HF receiver such as an Airspy HF+ type? How does that interact with your antenna and local noise?
4. If you use an SDR as a panadapter or bandscope next to a transceiver, how do you protect the SDR input and keep CAT/frequency tracking reliable?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10798-gain-dynamic-range-and-antennas-why-does-the-same-sdr-look-fine-on-one-band-and-overloaded-on-another/Share on other sites