Dual-band mobile setups: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and cross-band tips
- Replies 2
- Views 40
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for sorting out the practical side of running a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile rig, whether you're installing your first one or reworking a messy install. The three radios that come up most often are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. All three are dual-band FM mobiles in the 50 watt class, but they differ in what they emphasize.
The FTM-500D is built around Yaesu's C4FM digital (System Fusion) alongside analog FM. The ID-5100A is a D-STAR radio with a touchscreen-style interface. The TM-D710G is the APRS-focused one, with a built-in TNC and GPS support, and it's known for its dual-band control head and its packet and EchoLink-related features. Which one is best depends on what your local repeaters and your friends actually use. A digital mode is only useful if there's someone and something to talk to. Check your local repeater directory before you buy.
Here are the main install topics I'd like people to weigh in on.
Power wiring and fusing. A 50 W FM transmitter can pull roughly 11 to 14 amps on high power, depending on the model, so don't plan on a cigarette lighter socket. Run the supplied power cable, or a heavier equivalent, straight to the battery or a properly rated distribution point. The rule is to fuse the positive lead as close to the source as practical, because the fuse protects the wire, not just the radio. Use the fuse rating your manual specifies, and size the wire for the current and the length of the run. If you extend the cable, use wire at least as heavy as the original, and make crimps and connections solid. A loose power connection can show up as dropouts or strange resets on transmit.
Mounting. Pick a location where the radio gets airflow, you can reach the controls, and a crash or hard braking won't send it into your knees. Many people use a bracket under the dash or on the transmission tunnel. For a head that separates from the body, check which models support remote mounting and whether a separation kit is needed. Avoid mounting over airbag deployment zones.
Antenna and feedline. A well-placed antenna matters more than a few extra watts. A roof-center NMO mount gives the best ground plane and pattern, and a trunk lip or fender mount works when drilling isn't an option. UHF loses more signal in thin coax than VHF does, so a longer run of small coax costs you more at 440 MHz. Check SWR on both bands, since an antenna cut well for 2 meters can be less happy on 70 cm.
Noise suppression. Alternator whine that rises and falls with engine RPM usually points to power-line noise, while ticking that follows the engine often comes from ignition or other electronics. First check the basics: a good, bare-metal ground, power cable routed away from the coax, and a clean connection at the battery. Then work through other noise sources one at a time, such as aftermarket LED lighting, USB chargers, dash cameras and DC-DC converters, which can all radiate hash into receivers. Ferrites can help in some places, but treat them as a diagnostic step, not a first fix.
Cross-band repeat. This lets a mobile receive on one band and retransmit on the other, so a handheld with a weak signal can reach farther through the vehicle's antenna. It's a feature to confirm in your specific radio's manual, since support and setup differ by model and firmware. When you use it, you need a licensed control operator, you must identify as your rules require, and you should make sure you aren't pointing the retransmission at a repeater's input frequency. Watch heat on long transmissions and keep the handheld's antenna away from the mobile's antenna to avoid desense.
Mobile etiquette. Drive first. Know your local distracted-driving laws, and use a speaker mic, voice announcements or pre-set memories to minimize time looking at the screen. Listen before keying, keep transmissions short on busy repeaters, and give your callsign as required. Don't have lengthy technical conversations in heavy traffic or while navigating a complex junction.
What are you running, how are you mounting it, and what noise or wiring problem has given you the most trouble?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10824-dual-band-mobile-setups-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-cross-band-tips/Share on other sites