Small lot, HOA, no tower: how do you rank EFHW, OCFD, doublet, vertical and loop options by actual performance, not just SWR?
- Replies 2
- Views 33
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Take a typical constrained scenario: a 50 x 100 ft lot, a couple of tall trees, a neighborhood that doesn't welcome visible antennas, and a 100 W station that wants 80 through 10 m. The usual candidates are an end-fed half-wave (EFHW), an off-center fed dipole (OCFD), a G5RV or a doublet on ladder line, a ground-mounted or elevated-radial vertical, and a magnetic loop. Each gets recommended with a different argument, and the arguments often confuse SWR with performance.
The first point worth settling is that SWR only tells you how well the load matches the line at one point. A dummy load gives a perfect 1:1 and radiates nothing. A short loaded antenna over poor ground can show a flat match and still lose most of the power as heat. SWR matters for protecting the rig, for avoiding extra feedline loss, and for avoiding tuner stress. It says little about gain or takeoff angle.
Feedline loss is where SWR does matter. Coax loss is quoted for a matched line and rises with mismatch. Roughly, RG-213 loses around half a dB per 100 ft at 14 MHz when matched, and RG-58 loses about twice that. On 10 m the figures are higher still. A doublet at 3.5 MHz with a 10:1 SWR on a long run of thin coax can lose far more than expected. That's why doublets and G5RV-style antennas are normally fed with ladder line, with the transition to coax made through a tuner and a choke near the shack, so that the high-SWR section is the low-loss one.
Common-mode current is the other recurring problem. EFHWs, OCFDs and G5RVs all tend to put RF on the coax shield unless it's choked. The EFHW makes the shield part of the counterpoise by design, since the feedpoint is at a high-impedance voltage maximum, usually through a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer. A choke at the radio end, and sometimes a short counterpoise at the transformer, often cures RFI and the 'SWR changes when I touch the coax' symptom. An OCFD feeds at about a third of the length through a 4:1 current balun. It works well on its fundamental and harmonically related bands, and it is usually weaker on the WARC bands.
Height is the thing people underrate. A horizontal dipole at 30 ft is about 0.21 wavelength high on 40 m, which suits regional work but pushes much of the energy to high angles. On 20 m it's about 0.43 wavelength, and the pattern is much better for DX. On 80 m, any wire at that height behaves as a high-angle NVIS-type radiator. For an inverted V, keep the apex as high as possible, keep the included angle reasonably wide (above roughly 90 degrees if you can), and keep the ends well out of reach, because the voltage there is high.
Verticals have the opposite problem: the antenna is simple, but the ground system decides the efficiency. A quarter-wave vertical on the ground with only a handful of short radials can waste a large share of the power in ground loss. Many short radials (16 or more) or a few resonant elevated radials make a big difference. Short loaded verticals for 80 and 160 m are a trade-off in efficiency, no matter how good the SWR looks.
Magnetic loops attract stealth-minded operators because they're compact and quiet on receive. The trade-offs are high Q, very narrow bandwidth, retuning for every frequency change, kilovolt-level voltage across the capacitor at 100 W, and efficiency that depends heavily on conductor size and joint resistance. On the lower bands a small loop's efficiency can fall steeply.
For HOA situations, the practical tools are thin dark wire strung between trees, a flagpole-style vertical, or an attic antenna. Attic installs work but have to deal with wiring, ducts and roofing, which add loss and noise. Rules also differ. In the US, PRB-1 covers state and local government regulation, not private deed covenants, so check which one applies to you.
So, with a limited footprint, which compromise would you pick, and why? Is a single 40 m EFHW with a good choke a better starting point than a 130 ft doublet at lower height? And where would you draw the line on a loop or vertical for the lower bands?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10842-small-lot-hoa-no-tower-how-do-you-rank-efhw-ocfd-doublet-vertical-and-loop-options-by-actual-performance-not-just-swr/Share on other sites