J-pole, slim jim, 5/8 wave or yagi? Matching VHF/UHF antennas to polarization, pattern and feedline
- Replies 2
- Views 40
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Most VHF/UHF antenna problems come from a mismatch between the antenna type and the job, not from a bad antenna. This thread is a place to compare the common options and the parts around them (coax, connectors, mounts), because the feedline and installation often matter more than the antenna's catalog gain figure.
Simple verticals. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches on 2 m (roughly 6.5 inches on 70 cm). It needs a ground plane, such as a vehicle roof or radials, and has a fairly low-angle pattern with about unity gain over a ground plane. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and usually has a base matching coil. In theory it concentrates energy a little closer to the horizon, and gain figures of a couple of dB over a quarter-wave are typical, but real numbers depend heavily on the ground plane. A small or off-center ground plane can tilt the pattern upward and cost you the benefit.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave designs, with a quarter-wave matching section in the J-pole. Neither needs radials in the way a quarter-wave does, which is why they are popular as home-built antennas from ladder line, copper pipe or twin-lead. Gain is modest, roughly half-wave dipole territory, and vendor claims vary. The usual practical issue is common-mode current on the coax, which distorts the pattern and moves the SWR when you touch the cable. A choke (ferrite beads or a few turns of coax) near the feedpoint helps. A slim jim's folded design gives it a slightly lower takeoff angle than a J-pole, but you should treat any big gain number with suspicion.
Collinears. Stacking in-phase elements squeezes the vertical pattern. Ideally each doubling of the radiating section adds about 3 dB, but real antennas fall short because of phasing losses. The tradeoff is a narrower elevation beamwidth, so a high-gain omni can overshoot users who are close and well below it, for example from a hilltop. Mounting it away from the mast and keeping the mast vertical both matter.
Yagis. A yagi gives directional gain and front-to-back rejection. It can null out interference as well as reach a distant repeater or station. Polarization is the catch. FM simplex and repeaters are almost always vertical, while weak-signal SSB/CW work on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized signals can lose a lot, and the loss is rarely as clean as the theoretical figure because reflections scramble polarization.
Coax and connectors. Loss rises quickly with frequency. Rough figures per 100 ft are: RG-58 about 4.5 dB at 150 MHz and around 9 dB at 450 MHz; LMR-400-class cable about 1.5 dB and 2.7 dB. Always check the manufacturer's datasheet. A PL-259 (UHF connector) is fine for HF and workable on 2 m, but it is not constant-impedance and is a poor choice for 70 cm and above, especially outdoors. N-type is constant-impedance, better sealed and a better fit for UHF and permanent installs. Seal outdoor connectors with self-amalgamating tape plus a UV-resistant outer wrap, and leave a drip loop.
SWR. SWR indicates match, not efficiency. A 1.5:1 SWR reflects roughly 4% of power, and 2:1 about 11%, which is rarely the main loss. A dummy-load-quality reading through a long run of lossy coax can look excellent because the loss hides the reflection. If possible, measure at the antenna end of the cable with an analyzer or VNA and check where the resonance actually sits.
Questions to get things started: for a fixed 2 m/70 cm base station, when does a homemade J-pole or slim jim make sense over a commercial collinear? And for a vehicle, how much does ground-plane geometry change the real-world difference between a 1/4-wave and a 5/8-wave?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10856-j-pole-slim-jim-58-wave-or-yagi-matching-vhfuhf-antennas-to-polarization-pattern-and-feedline/Share on other sites