EFHW or linked dipole for a quick SOTA/POTA setup? Plus what else belongs in the go-kit
- Replies 2
- Views 51
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Portable antenna choice usually comes down to two popular wire options, the end-fed half wave (EFHW) and the linked dipole. Both work well for SOTA and POTA, but they suit different habits. Here is how they compare, and I'd like to hear where people draw the line.
EFHW. A typical EFHW is a half-wavelength wire on the lowest band, fed at one end through a matching transformer (commonly 49:1 or 64:1). A 40 m version is roughly 20 m (66 ft) long and is usually resonant on 40, 20, 15 and 10 m without changing anything. That is the big attraction: put it up, pick a band, and often skip the tuner. The trade-offs are that the feedpoint is sensitive to what's near it, and there is no true balanced feed. A short counterpoise wire, a common-mode choke, or both often make a noticeable difference to SWR and to RF getting back onto the coax. Different layouts (sloper, inverted-L, inverted-V) can also shift resonance a bit, so trimming and checking with an analyzer before leaving home saves frustration.
Linked dipole. A center-fed dipole with sections joined by small connectors, so you add or remove wire to change bands. It's predictable and balanced, usually with a 1:1 choke at the feed, and it tends to give a good match on each band it is cut for. The cost is time and fiddling: to change band you have to lower the pole or reach the links, which gets annoying in wind, rain or cold fingers. It also needs a longer, more careful setup than a single wire hung from a mast.
Supports. A fiberglass telescopic pole in the 7 to 10 m (about 23 to 33 ft) range is the usual choice. Practical points that come up again and again: clean the sections and check the collapsed length against your pack. Use guy lines and stakes or a mount rather than leaning the pole on something. Keep every part of the pole and wire well away from power lines. Don't rely on a pole standing in a stiff wind without guying. On a SOTA summit with no trees, a lighter 5 to 6 m pole with an inverted-V can be far less hassle than a tall one.
Power. LiFePO4 is popular because it's light, tolerates many cycles, and holds fairly steady voltage under load. A 4S pack is about 12.8 V nominal and about 14.4 to 14.6 V fully charged, which is higher than the 13.8 V many radios are designed around, so check your radio's input range. Very low-power QRP radios are usually fine, but verify. If you charge from solar, use a controller or charger with a LiFePO4 profile, and avoid charging LiFePO4 cells below freezing unless the pack has low-temperature protection. Fuse the positive lead close to the battery, and use polarized connectors you can't plug in backward.
Logging and rules. A paper log with UTC times is a solid backup that doesn't run out of battery. If you use a phone app, make sure it works offline and exports ADIF. For a valid POTA activation you need 10 QSOs within a UTC day, and SOTA needs 4 contacts for the summit to count. Rules and program details change, so check the current requirements before you go. Also, spotting often needs cell coverage, so plan how you'll get spotted or whether you'll call CQ cold.
Weather and safety. Treat lightning as a hard stop: no pole or wire in the air when thunderstorms are near. Check the forecast for wind and temperature drops on exposed summits, and tell someone your location and return time. Carry water, layers and a basic first-aid kit. Hot parked cars and cold ridgelines are both worse for batteries than people expect.
So, for quick park activations and summit hikes, where do you land: the single-wire EFHW for speed, or the linked dipole for a predictable match? And what small item in your go-kit ends up saving the day more than you'd expect?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10870-efhw-or-linked-dipole-for-a-quick-sotapota-setup-plus-what-else-belongs-in-the-go-kit/Share on other sites