How do you decide if a band is really open: SFI and K-index, or live spots from WSPR and beacons?
- Replies 2
- Views 40
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Propagation advice tends to split into two camps. One camp reads the numbers (SFI, A and K index, X-ray flux) and predicts what should happen. The other ignores the numbers and checks what is being heard right now on WSPR, PSK Reporter, the Reverse Beacon Network or the beacons. I'd like to compare how people combine the two, because each one has blind spots.
Here is the basic framework as I understand it. The 10.7 cm solar flux (SFI) is a proxy for the solar ultraviolet and EUV output that ionizes the F2 layer. Higher SFI usually means a higher MUF, so 15, 12 and 10 m become more usable in daylight. It is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee. Season, local time, latitude and path geometry all matter, and the ionosphere often does something the number doesn't predict. Keep in mind that SFI is a single daily number, while the ionosphere changes by the hour.
The A index is a daily average of geomagnetic disturbance, and the K index is a 3-hour value on a quasi-logarithmic 0-9 scale. Low and steady values are generally good for HF, especially on paths that cross high latitudes. When K rises into the 4-5 range or higher, expect disturbed F2 conditions, more absorption and flutter on polar paths, and often a depressed MUF. Be careful about trend versus snapshot. A K of 2 that has just come down from a storm doesn't always mean conditions have recovered.
The D layer matters most in the daytime. It forms on the sunlit side and absorbs lower HF signals, which is why 160, 80 and often 40 m are weak over long distances in daylight, but can open up once the path goes dark. A solar flare can cause a sudden ionospheric disturbance, and it can wipe out HF on the sunlit hemisphere for minutes to hours. That is the case where the numbers (X-ray flux) and the live spots both agree, and fast.
VHF is a different problem. Sporadic E, which peaks in the northern-hemisphere early summer with a smaller peak around midwinter, can make 10 m, 6 m and sometimes 2 m behave in ways that SFI cannot explain. Tropospheric ducting depends on weather (inversions, high-pressure systems, over-water paths) and not on the Sun at all. So "the SFI is low" doesn't mean 50 MHz and above are dead.
For planning, VOACAP is useful, but it is a model based on smoothed monthly median conditions. Use it to compare bands and times of day for a given path, power and antenna, and don't treat its reliability figure as a live forecast. Then use live tools for confirmation. NCDXF/IARU beacons on 14.100, 18.110, 21.150, 24.930 and 28.200 MHz cycle through a three-minute schedule with four power steps (100 W down to 0.1 W), so hearing the lower-power steps tells you quite a lot about how good the path really is. WSPR gives you spots with SNR numbers, but remember that those depend on who is listening and where, so a lack of spots may mean there are no receivers, not that the band is closed.
Questions for the thread: Which sources do you check first? How do you handle gray line and NVIS planning, for instance when foF2 drops below the frequency you wanted for local coverage? And do you trust a predicted opening that nobody has spotted yet?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10893-how-do-you-decide-if-a-band-is-really-open-sfi-and-k-index-or-live-spots-from-wspr-and-beacons/Share on other sites