VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole vs collinear vs 5/8 whip, and why coax and connectors often matter more than the antenna
- Replies 2
- Views 89
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Here is a common 2 m / 70 cm question: you want a decent vertical antenna for FM repeaters and simplex, you might want to try a satellite pass later, and you have to pick between a J-pole or Slim Jim, a collinear, a mobile whip on a mag mount or NMO, and maybe a small yagi. The numbers in catalogs make it look like you can just buy the most dBi. In practice, pattern, polarization, feedline loss, and installation usually decide how well the system works.
Start with gain. Always check whether it is quoted in dBd (relative to a half-wave dipole) or dBi (relative to an isotropic radiator). The difference is 2.15 dB, which is why some ads look generous. Gain in a vertical antenna is not free power. It comes from squeezing the pattern in elevation, so the antenna sends more energy toward the horizon and less up and down. That is useful on flat terrain or when you are talking to a distant repeater. It can hurt when you are in hills, on a steep slope, or very close to a repeater sitting well above you.
A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches (roughly 48 cm) on 2 m. It needs a ground plane, and a vehicle roof is ideal. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and uses a loading coil or matching network at the base. In the ideal case it has roughly 3 dB more gain than a quarter-wave and a lower takeoff angle. It also depends more on a good ground plane, so a poor mounting location can erase much of that advantage.
The J-pole is an end-fed half-wave radiator with a quarter-wave matching stub. The Slim Jim is a similar idea with the structure folded. Both are roughly half-wave-class antennas, so be skeptical of claims of large gain. The less obvious issue is that they have no real ground plane. If the coax is simply hung from the bottom, the outside of the shield can carry current and become part of the antenna. That distorts the pattern and can change the SWR as you move the cable. A choke (ferrite beads or a few turns of coax) near the feedpoint helps, as does running the coax away from the antenna at a right angle where practical.
So the questions are these. What do you actually need: a compact omni, more reach toward a known repeater, or something you can take down and carry? And where does the antenna have to sit, on a roof, a mast, a balcony, or a vehicle? Pick the pattern for the geometry first, then pick the hardware.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10913-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-collinear-vs-58-whip-and-why-coax-and-connectors-often-matter-more-than-the-antenna/Share on other sites