Small-yard HF antennas: how to compare EFHW, OCFD, G5RV, doublet and vertical options without trusting SWR alone
- Replies 2
- Views 37
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
A common small-lot question goes: "I have about 50 to 70 feet of usable space, a couple of tall supports or a tree, and an HOA that dislikes anything obvious. What should I put up?" The answers usually turn into a fight between EFHW, OCFD, G5RV, doublet and vertical camps, and the argument is usually about SWR. SWR is a poor way to rank antennas, so here is a framework for the comparison.
SWR only tells you how well the load at the end of the feed line matches the line and radio. A dummy load is a perfect 1:1 and radiates nothing. A short, lossy antenna can show a flat match while converting much of your power to heat. What matters for performance is radiation efficiency, pattern, takeoff angle and total system loss, and SWR affects only the last of these, through added feed line loss.
That loss is where coax choices matter. Coax loss rises with frequency and with mismatch. A short run of RG-213 at 14 MHz is nearly negligible even at a modest SWR. A long run of thin coax such as RG-58 on 10 meters feeding a 3:1 load can waste a noticeable share of your power. This is the strongest argument for balanced line (ladder line or window line) on multiband antennas that will be tuned far from resonance. A doublet or a G5RV-style antenna fed with ladder line and a good tuner can often beat a "resonant" antenna fed with long, lossy coax.
Height above ground is the next big factor, and it is easy to underrate. A horizontal dipole at 0.5 wavelength has a useful low-angle lobe for DX. At 0.15 to 0.25 wavelength it behaves more like an NVIS radiator, with a strong high-angle lobe and weaker low-angle signal. For example, a 40 m dipole at 30 ft is roughly 0.2 wavelength up and will work well for regional contacts, but it is not a great DX antenna. On 20 m the same wire is closer to 0.45 wavelength and the pattern improves. Inverted Vs trade some low-angle performance and bandwidth for needing only one tall support, and the ends can be tied off low. They need a slightly shorter wire than a flat-top dipole, and the feed impedance drops as the included angle tightens.
On the specific designs:
EFHW: a half-wave wire fed at one end through a high-ratio transformer (commonly 49:1 or 64:1). A 40 m version is resonant on 40, 20, 15 and 10 because those are harmonics, but 30 m and 17 m are not harmonically related and usually need a tuner or a different design. Because the feed is at high impedance, the current on the transformer's "ground" side has to go somewhere, so the coax shield often serves as a counterpoise. A common-mode choke at the radio end helps keep RF out of the shack. The wire end carries very high voltage, which matters for safety, especially at power or near people and pets. Transformer core losses and heating also vary a lot between builds.
OCFD (Windom-style): the feedpoint sits roughly a third of the way along the wire, with a 4:1 current balun or similar. A 40 m-based OCFD can work on 40, 20, 10 and sometimes 15 m, but the impedance and pattern vary by band and the match is rarely perfect everywhere. Common-mode current on the coax is a frequent complaint, so a good choke is worth having.
G5RV: roughly 102 ft of dipole fed with a matching section of ladder line, then coax. It was designed around 20 m, where the matching section acts like a useful length. On other bands it is essentially a doublet that needs a tuner. The half-size 51 ft version is popular for small lots but covers lower bands less efficiently. It is a reasonable compromise, but not a magic multiband resonant antenna.
Doublet: a flat-top of arbitrary length fed with ladder line into a balanced tuner or a tuner with a good 4:1 or 1:1 balun. Avoid lengths that give extreme feedpoint impedance on your favorite bands, where the tuner and line may see very high voltage or current. It is a flexible, low-loss and often underrated option.
Trap dipoles and other loaded antennas: traps shorten the antenna and make multiband use convenient, but they narrow bandwidth and add loss compared with a full-size dipole on each band. They are a good solution for tight spaces, though not free of compromise.
Verticals: a ground-mounted quarter-wave vertical depends heavily on its radial field. Many buried or surface radials improve efficiency, and a handful will work but at lower efficiency. An elevated vertical with several tuned radials (often 2 to 4 per band, sloped or horizontal) can work well with fewer wires, and the feed impedance is closer to 50 ohms when radials slope downward. Verticals tend to give a lower takeoff angle, which is good for DX, but they can be noisier on receive and weaker on near-in contacts than a horizontal wire.
Loops: a full-wave horizontal loop is a very good small-yard antenna if you can support the perimeter, since it has good efficiency and relatively low noise. A magnetic loop is a different animal: a small, high-Q loop with a variable capacitor. Efficiency depends on conductor size, joint quality and capacitor losses. Bandwidth is very narrow, so you retune when you move a few kHz, and the capacitor sees very high voltage. It can be useful where nothing else fits, but it is a compromise antenna.
Yagis and other beams: gain and front-to-back ratio are the prize, and even a three-element beam can add several dB over a dipole, but you need a tower or mast, a rotator, and permission. For HOA situations a small beam is rarely the first thing to try.
For stealth installations, thin dark wire between trees, a flagpole-style vertical, an attic dipole, or a wire along a fence line can be nearly invisible. Attic antennas are subject to losses from nearby wiring, ducts and insulation, and any antenna close to living space needs thought about RF exposure and interference to household electronics.
Where would you start if you had one 60-ft run and a single 30-ft support? Would you go with a resonant dipole or inverted V, an EFHW, or a doublet with ladder line and tuner?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10926-small-yard-hf-antennas-how-to-compare-efhw-ocfd-g5rv-doublet-and-vertical-options-without-trusting-swr-alone/Share on other sites