ARES vs. RACES vs. SKYWARN vs. CERT: how do you organize training so you're actually useful at an EOC or net?
- Replies 2
- Views 31
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
Many new hams ask which group they should join: ARES, RACES, SKYWARN, CERT, or MARS. The answer is usually that these are different tools, and a well-prepared operator knows which one applies to a given situation. I'd like to compare notes on how to build a training path that makes sense, and where people see the gaps in local programs.
Here's the short version of how the programs differ. ARES is the ARRL's volunteer emergency communications program. It is organized locally, usually by county or section, and it serves agencies such as emergency management, hospitals, the Red Cross and the Salvation Army. RACES is a government-authorized service under FCC Part 97 rules, tied to a state or local emergency management agency. Its operating rules are specific: drills and tests are limited in time, and activation comes through the governmental authority, not just the radio club. Many operators are enrolled in both, so the real question is who is calling you out and under what authority. SKYWARN is the National Weather Service's spotter program. It is about ground-truth weather reports, not served-agency communications, though the nets often overlap with ham operators. CERT is a community response team model with its own training in light search and rescue, triage and fire safety, and radio use is only one part of it. MARS is a separate military-affiliated auxiliary with its own membership and procedures, not a ham club activity.
For training, a common baseline is the FEMA Independent Study courses on ICS and NIMS: IS-100, IS-200, IS-700, and often IS-800. These are free online. Beyond that, ARRL offers emergency communications courses, and many local groups run their own net control and message handling workshops. I'd like to hear how others sequence these. Do you start with ICS, or with net procedures and message forms?
A few practical areas where I think groups often have gaps:
First, message handling. Many operators can chat on a repeater but have never moved a formal message accurately. In a served-agency setting you're likely to use an ICS-213 form or a radiogram-style format, and the job is to deliver the text exactly as written, with no paraphrasing. Practicing with phonetics, clear word counts and read-backs matters more than fancy equipment.
Second, net control. A good net control station states the purpose of the net, keeps check-ins short, assigns tactical call signs where it helps, takes emergency and priority traffic first, and keeps a log. Plain language is generally preferred over 10-codes. Station identification with your FCC call sign still applies, so tactical names do not replace it.
Third, go-bags. People tend to over-pack radios and under-pack the boring items: spare batteries or a charging plan, a simple antenna set, headset or earpiece, paper and pencil, log sheets, copies of your credentials and the agency contact list, water and food, medications, weather gear, and a reflective vest if your group's plan calls for one. Check what your served agency actually expects before deploying, since credential and safety requirements vary by jurisdiction.
Fourth, knowing the plan. County and state emergency operations plans usually describe where communications support fits, who can request it, and what the chain of command looks like. If your group has never read the communications annex, that is a good first meeting topic.
For discussion: what has worked for you in exercises, and what do you wish your group practiced more? I'm especially curious about EOC operations, such as how to work as a radio operator in a room full of other staff without becoming a bottleneck, and how groups handle simplex and repeater failures during an exercise.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10933-ares-vs-races-vs-skywarn-vs-cert-how-do-you-organize-training-so-youre-actually-useful-at-an-eoc-or-net/Share on other sites