Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75 (and where the IC-705 and DMR fit), plus CHIRP, offsets and batteries
- Replies 2
- Views 128
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
A lot of new-ham HT questions come down to "what should I buy first?" and "why won't it hit the repeater?" Here is a rough framework for discussion, and corrections are welcome. I'm assuming US band plans unless noted. Check your local plan and licensing rules.
Analog FM dual-banders. The Yaesu FT-65R is a straightforward 2 m/70 cm analog FM handheld at roughly 5 W. It has no GPS, no digital modes and no Bluetooth, so there is little to learn and little to break. Budget Baofeng models such as the UV-5R family cost much less and are well supported in CHIRP. The trade-offs are usually receiver selectivity, spurious emissions on some models, menu quirks and variable build quality. For a first radio, many people prefer a known-good analog HT for local repeaters and simplex, then add digital later.
D-STAR handhelds. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band (2 m/70 cm) D-STAR and analog FM handheld with GPS and Bluetooth. The Kenwood TH-D75 is a tri-band (2 m, 1.25 m, 70 cm) with D-STAR, built-in GPS and APRS. D-STAR needs you to register your callsign with the network before reflector and gateway functions work properly. It is only worth paying for if D-STAR repeaters or reflectors are active in your area, so check local coverage first.
The IC-705. Strictly speaking it isn't an HT. It's a compact portable HF/50 MHz/VHF/UHF all-mode transceiver with D-STAR. Output is about 5 W on its own battery and up to 10 W on external DC. It makes sense as a field or SOTA/POTA-style radio, but it is not a pocket radio. Comparing it with the FT-65R is comparing different tools.
DMR. DMR handhelds from AnyTone, Radioddity, TYT and others are popular and relatively cheap, but they work differently. You need a DMR ID, a codeplug (the channel, talkgroup and contact setup), and some understanding of timeslots and talkgroups. The codeplug is the biggest hurdle. Starting from a well-maintained codeplug for your region is usually easier than building one from scratch.
Antennas and batteries. Stock rubber ducks are a compromise. A better 2 m/70 cm whip, or a roll-up J-pole for a fixed location, often improves performance more than a new radio does. Check the connector first. Many handhelds use SMA-female on the radio, and Baofeng/Kenwood/Yaesu variants are not always the same. Carry a spare battery pack, and consider a battery case that takes AA cells as a backup. Don't leave Li-ion packs fully discharged for long periods.
CHIRP and offsets. CHIRP is free, open-source programming software that supports many models, though not every radio, so check the supported list first. Always download an image from the radio before changing anything, and save the file. Cheap programming cables with unreliable chips cause plenty of "it won't connect" posts. Repeater entries need frequency, duplex direction, offset and CTCSS (PL) tone. In the US, 2 m is usually ±600 kHz and 70 cm is usually ±5 MHz, with 1.25 m typically −1.6 MHz. Other regions differ, for example many European 70 cm repeaters use 7.6 MHz. Always confirm against a current repeater directory or the repeater owner's information.
Emergency use. Programming a radio for emergencies is mostly about preparation: local repeaters, simplex channels, weather channels, and any net frequencies your local group uses. Print a channel list, label your memories clearly, and practice with the radio before you need it. Remember that transmit privileges depend on licensing and radio type. Don't transmit on bands you are not licensed for, and note that GMRS and FRS rules differ from amateur rules.
What would you recommend for a first handheld, and would you start with analog or go straight to digital?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10938-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-and-dmr-fit-plus-chirp-offsets-and-batteries/Share on other sites