Turning SET and Field Day into real disaster-comms practice: what to test, what to write down, and how to make the after-action report useful
- Replies 2
- Views 124
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Most of us agree that exercises matter, but a lot of them end up as a pleasant afternoon on the air followed by a vague "it went well" summary. I'd like to start a discussion on how to get more value from the Simulated Emergency Test (SET), Field Day and local drills, so that what we learn actually changes how we respond to hurricanes, wildfires, floods, earthquakes, tornadoes and grid failures.
Here are a few starting points. Please push back, add your own, or tell us what you'd change.
1. Pick one or two objectives per exercise. Trying to test everything tends to test nothing. Examples of objectives that can be measured:
2. Treat Field Day as practice for deployment, not just a contest. Field Day is a good chance to rehearse setup speed, power, antennas, logging, shift changes and station layout. If you want it to double as emergency practice, add a few deliberate extras: a timed setup, a "no commercial power" rule, a message-handling table, and someone assigned to watch for problems (tangled cables, dead batteries, RF in the audio, missing adapters) and write them down.
3. Write net scripts that people can follow under stress. A good script is short, with plain language and blanks to fill in. Useful pieces include:
Keep a backup copy on paper. Phones and tablets die, and printed scripts don't need power.
4. Practice message handling, not only voice checks. A checkin that says "I can hear you" is useful, but the real work is moving content accurately. Things worth drilling: writing the message exactly as given, reading back numbers and unusual words, using phonetics where needed, recording times, and avoiding paraphrase. Include a few messages that are inconvenient on purpose, such as ones with long lists, street addresses, medical supply quantities or names with odd spellings.
5. Bring the served agency into the planning. The best exercise is one a served agency (emergency management, a hospital, a shelter operator, the Red Cross, etc.) actually helps shape. Ask them what information they would need to send, to whom, how fast and in what format. Find out whether they'd want radio operators embedded at a location or only on call, what credentialing or identification is required, who is the point of contact, and what the chain of command looks like. We should be adapting to their forms and terminology rather than expecting them to learn ours. Plain language matters: avoid Q-signals and ham slang when speaking to agency staff.
6. Build scenarios around the failure, not just the hazard. A hurricane scenario might emphasize power loss, fuel and long-duration operations, evacuation and shelter reporting. Wildfire might stress changing conditions, smoke, repeater site access and evacuation route status. Floods bring blocked roads and isolated operators. Earthquakes raise questions about damaged infrastructure and sudden overload of the net. Tornadoes involve short timelines and spotter-style reports. A grid failure tests battery, generator and fuel plans, plus whether any of your repeaters have backup power. Inject realistic problems mid-exercise: a repeater drops, net control has to hand off, an operator has to leave, a message arrives with missing information.
7. Capture observations in real time. Appoint an observer or two and give them a simple form: time, what happened, what was expected, who was involved. Memory fades quickly, and the notes people take on the spot are far more useful than recollection a week later.
8. Make the after-action report short and specific. A structure that works well is: objectives, what happened, what worked, what didn't, root cause, and corrective actions with a named owner and a target date. "Improve communication" isn't an action. "Add a laminated frequency card to each go-kit and verify by the next quarterly meeting" is. Then, at the next exercise, check whether the previous items were closed.
Questions for the group:
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10944-turning-set-and-field-day-into-real-disaster-comms-practice-what-to-test-what-to-write-down-and-how-to-make-the-after-action-report-useful/Share on other sites