Planning a dual-band mobile install (FTM-500D, ID-5100A or TM-D710G): wiring, noise, cross-band and mobile manners
- Replies 2
- Views 103
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
I'm starting a thread for anyone putting a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile into a vehicle or revisiting an install that isn't working well. The three radios that come up most often are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. All three are 50 W-class dual-banders, but they differ in what they emphasize: digital modes, APRS, display style and extra features.
Here is a rough way to frame the choice. The FTM-500D is built around Yaesu's C4FM digital voice (System Fusion) alongside analog FM. The ID-5100A is Icom's D-STAR mobile, with a large touchscreen. The TM-D710G is a long-running analog FM radio with built-in APRS and a TNC. If your local repeaters are mostly analog, any of them works fine. If your area is heavy on one digital mode, that should drive the decision more than the spec sheet does. Check the current manual for each radio before relying on any feature, because firmware and regional versions vary.
The install matters as much as the radio, so here are the questions I'd like to discuss.
Power wiring and fusing. The usual advice is to run power directly to the battery rather than tapping a cigarette lighter socket or an accessory circuit. A 50 W FM radio can draw roughly a dozen amps or more on transmit, and shared circuits can sag and add noise. Keep the fuse on the positive lead as close to the battery terminal as practical, and fuse each leg if the radio's cable has two fuse holders. Use the wire gauge the manufacturer specifies as a minimum, and go heavier for a long run. Protect the cable with a grommet where it passes through the firewall, and keep it away from sharp edges and hot components.
Mounting. Put the radio body somewhere that gets airflow, will not shift in a hard stop, and is not in an airbag deployment area. Many people mount the body under a seat or on the transmission tunnel and put the control head on the dash. Whatever you do, the mic and cables should not be able to interfere with the pedals or the driver's movement.
Antenna. A dual-band antenna on a roof-center NMO mount is a common good starting point because the metal roof acts as the ground plane. Check SWR on both bands after installing, since a poor ground or a bad coax connection will show up there. Poor SWR can also make noise problems seem worse.
Noise. Alternator whine, ignition noise, aftermarket LED lighting, USB chargers and DC-DC converters are common sources. FM is more forgiving than SSB, but you'll still hear it as a raised noise floor or a squelch that won't stay closed. Try turning accessories off one at a time to find the source. Ferrite cores, a clean power path and separating the radio's power cable from other wiring will often help.
Cross-band repeat. This is where the radios differ, and I'd rather not assume. The TM-D710G is well known for having a cross-band repeat function. For the FTM-500D and ID-5100A, check the manual or manufacturer specs for your version. If you use cross-band repeat, you're still responsible for the transmissions, so identify as your rules require, use the lowest power that works, and watch heat on long retransmissions. Also check that this kind of operation is allowed under your license and local regulations.
Etiquette. Drive first. Use hands-free or voice-friendly controls, keep transmissions short, and don't program the radio while the car is moving. On a repeater, leave a gap between transmissions so others can break in, and avoid long conversations on busy machines.
What are your priorities: digital capability, APRS, or simply a reliable analog FM radio? And if you have an install that isn't behaving, what are the symptoms?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10953-planning-a-dual-band-mobile-install-ftm-500d-id-5100a-or-tm-d710g-wiring-noise-cross-band-and-mobile-manners/Share on other sites