When is a multiplier worth leaving your run frequency? Run vs S&P, SO2R and band-change decisions
- Replies 2
- Views 61
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Most contest decisions come down to one question: should the next minute go toward more QSOs, or toward a multiplier? I'd like to compare how people make that call, and here is a framework to start from.
Take the simple score model: score = QSO points × multipliers. One more QSO adds roughly your points-per-QSO times your current multiplier count. One more multiplier adds your total QSO points. So a new multiplier is worth about Q/M QSOs, where Q is your QSO count and M is your multiplier count. With 1,000 QSOs and 100 multipliers, each new multiplier is worth about 10 average QSOs. Early in the contest, when M is small, multipliers are worth very little in QSO terms. Late in the contest, when M is large and the easy ones are logged, each one is worth more, but also costs more to find.
The other half is cost. If you are running at 150/hr, you are making about 2.5 QSOs a minute. Dropping the run to chase a multiplier costs the QSOs you would have made, plus the risk that someone takes your frequency. That is why a run frequency that is producing deserves protection. A thin run of 40/hr is a different story. Tuning for multipliers on a band that has just opened may be the better use of the hour.
Band changes have the same trade-off. On a band with a good run, leaving costs you the rate, and you may not get the frequency back. In contests with per-band multipliers, a new band can reset your multiplier count and make early QSOs there worth more. That is one reason to move at the right moment rather than only when a band dies. A rate-sheet comparison of the last hour per band is more reliable than a gut feeling. N1MM's rate displays and band-by-band summaries make the comparison easy, but only if you look at them at planned intervals rather than when you are already frustrated.
SO2R changes the calculation. The second radio can search for multipliers while the first radio runs, so a multiplier costs less than a full frequency abandonment. The costs are real, though: switching latency, split attention, interference between radios, and callsign errors if your ears are on the wrong receiver. Typical setup issues include bandpass filtering when both radios are on nearby bands, antenna separation or stubs, stereo audio split between left and right ears, a footswitch or hotkey for TX focus, and keyer or voice message timing so the CQ repeat leaves enough gap to listen on radio 2.
Skimmers and packet spotting add another layer. Spots, whether from a telnet cluster or a local CW skimmer, can fill the bandmap with candidates, and you can quickly work needed multipliers without tuning blindly. But skimmer spots can be busted calls, especially on weak or QSB signals, so many operators confirm the call by ear and check it against a call history or Super Check Partial before logging. Also check your entry category: assisted classes allow spots, unassisted classes generally do not. Rules differ by contest and by year, so read the current ones.
Some questions for the thread:
How do you decide when to leave a working run for a multiplier? Do you use a fixed rule, such as a rate threshold or a multiplier-value estimate, or do you decide by feel?
For SO2R, what limits you more: the station (filters, antenna isolation, audio routing) or the operator (attention, switching discipline)?
And for long contests, how do you plan rest around propagation, so your off-times fall when rate is naturally lowest rather than when you happen to be tired?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10964-when-is-a-multiplier-worth-leaving-your-run-frequency-run-vs-sp-so2r-and-band-change-decisions/Share on other sites