Getting started with EME: what separates a 2 m JT65 station from a 23 cm or 10 GHz dish station?
- Replies 2
- Views 92
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
A thread for comparing notes on what it takes to make Earth-Moon-Earth contacts across the bands. Everything below is a rough planning guide, not a promise that any particular antenna will work. Check your own link budget before buying hardware.
Start with path loss, because it explains most of the equipment differences. The round trip to the Moon is roughly 250 dB on 144 MHz. It rises about 20 log(f) with frequency, so it is around 260 dB on 432 MHz, 270 dB on 1296 MHz and close to 290 dB on 10 GHz. The Moon's distance also changes the loss. Between perigee and apogee that is about 2 dB over the round trip. Perigee weekends are popular for a reason.
On 2 m, the usual JT65 or Q65 station is a group of long Yagis. Four is a common starting point, and larger arrays make contacts easier. Gain from the array matters, but so does keeping feedline loss down. Every dB lost between the amplifier and antenna hurts on transmit, and every dB lost ahead of the preamp hurts on receive. That is why people put a low-noise preamp at the antenna, use sequenced relays, and use heavy low-loss line. A preamp with a noise figure well under 1 dB is normal here. On 2 m, galactic noise often dominates the sky temperature, so a better preamp may help less than you expect when the Moon sits in a noisy part of the sky.
On 70 cm, the same total gain takes less physical size. That is the attraction, but there is also less margin for sloppy pointing. Many stations use Yagi arrays, and a 3 to 4 m dish is also a reasonable approach. Beamwidth is much narrower than on 2 m, so a tracking system that is a few degrees out will cost you.
On 23 cm, dishes dominate. A feed that is well matched to the dish, a preamp at the feed with minimal loss, and a decent transmit amplifier matter more than raw power. At 10 GHz and above, a good dish and a stable mount can make the difference. The Moon is about half a degree across, and a dish of a few metres at 10 GHz has a beamwidth of well under a degree. Mechanical backlash and tracking error become real problems.
Polarization is where the lower bands get complicated. Faraday rotation through the ionosphere is strong on 144 MHz and scales roughly with 1/f². It is milder on 432 MHz and negligible from the 23 cm band upward. A linearly polarized 2 m signal can therefore fade deeply as the rotation changes, and signals may come and go over minutes. Horizontal-only antennas lose signal when the rotation and the geometry between the two stations move the polarization away from the receive antenna. Solutions include antennas that can rotate polarization, or crossed Yagis with a way to switch or combine polarizations. On 23 cm and up, many stations use circular polarization. The reflection reverses the sense, so check what your partner is using and whether you can switch senses.
Libration fading is a different effect. The Moon's apparent motion makes the reflected signal arrive spread over a range of Doppler shifts. This produces rapid flutter-type fading that increases with frequency. It matters little on 2 m and becomes serious on microwaves, where a narrow tone mode can be smeared. This is part of why Q65 has several submodes with different tone spacing for different bands.
Software and sked planning are the final pieces. WSJT-X offers JT65 and Q65, and Q65 is generally more tolerant than JT65 of Doppler spread and offers better sensitivity. For the exact submode recommendation on your band, read the current WSJT-X documentation. Q65 submode A is typically used on 2 m, with wider spacing at higher frequencies. Doppler shift is a few hundred hertz on 2 m and tens of kilohertz at 10 GHz, so use Doppler tracking and, where practical, check your own echoes before trying a sked. Plan for both stations having the Moon above the horizon at the same time, with good elevation for each. Also compare sky noise, Moon declination, and polarization conditions in a planner such as MoonSked.
Questions for the group: what tracking software and pointing-check methods work for you? How do you decide between a Yagi array and a dish at 70 cm? And what is a realistic first-contact target on 2 m with a modest array?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10968-getting-started-with-eme-what-separates-a-2-m-jt65-station-from-a-23-cm-or-10-ghz-dish-station/Share on other sites