Choosing a first (or next) handheld: FT-65R vs. Baofeng vs. ID-52A vs. TH-D75, and where the IC-705 fits
- Replies 2
- Views 34
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Mike 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
I'd like to get a discussion going on handheld choices, because the same question keeps coming up in different forms: "What HT should I buy?" The answer depends on whether you want a cheap analog FM radio for local repeaters, a digital-voice handheld, or something to anchor an emergency kit. Here's one way to split the field, and I'd like to hear where people disagree.
Budget analog dual-banders. The Baofeng UV-5R family is the usual starting point because of the price and the huge ecosystem of batteries, antennas and programming cables. The Yaesu FT-65R sits a step up as a 2 m/70 cm analog FM handheld from a major manufacturer, with a simpler menu and a reputation for a more usable receiver. Neither does digital voice. If your local repeaters are all FM, that may be fine. One caution on the cheapest imports: transmit filtering and type acceptance vary a lot by model, so check the current regulations in your country before buying, and remember you need an amateur license to transmit on ham bands.
D-STAR and multimode. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band handheld that does analog FM and D-STAR DV, with GPS and Bluetooth. The Kenwood TH-D75 also does D-STAR and adds APRS, GPS and Bluetooth, and the North American version includes the 220 MHz band alongside 2 m and 70 cm. Both cost far more than an FT-65R or a Baofeng, and both are only worth it if you'll actually use the extra modes. D-STAR needs a callsign registration with the network and a decent amount of radio setup (MYCALL, URCALL, RPT1/RPT2) before it feels natural.
DMR. Handhelds like the Anytone and TYT lines are common here, and some are cheap. DMR is less plug-and-play than FM. You need a codeplug with talkgroups, time slots and color codes, plus a DMR ID registered through RadioID. If your area has active DMR repeaters or hotspots, it can be rewarding, but expect a learning curve.
The IC-705. It isn't a handheld in the HT sense. It's a compact portable transceiver covering HF, 6 m, 2 m and 70 cm, with D-STAR on the VHF/UHF side. It's bigger and costs more than any HT above, and for HF/SSB portable operation it's a different category. It's worth mentioning because people sometimes compare it with the ID-52A for the D-STAR features. For pure pocket-sized repeater use, it's probably the wrong tool.
Programming. CHIRP is the common free tool for loading memories on many analog radios, including popular Baofeng and Yaesu models. Check the supported-radio list on the CHIRP site for your exact model and firmware before you buy. Support for newer digital models can lag, and some radios are better served by the manufacturer's own software. Always download the radio's current configuration first and save it as a backup image before uploading anything.
Repeater offsets. Offsets are band-plan dependent. In the US, 2 m repeaters typically use ±600 kHz and 70 cm typically ±5 MHz, but local coordination decides the direction and the required CTCSS/PL tone. Europe and other regions differ. Don't enter an offset from memory. Look up the repeater in a current local directory and match the output frequency, offset direction and tone exactly. Many "I can hear it but can't get in" problems are a missing or wrong tone on transmit.
Batteries and antennas. Two cheap upgrades matter more than most feature differences. One is a spare battery pack, or a pack that takes AA cells if your model offers one. The other is a better antenna than the stock rubber duck, or at least a longer whip or a roll-up J-pole for fixed use. Check whether your radio has an SMA-female or SMA-male connector before ordering antennas, since the genders differ between brands.
Emergency use. Before an emergency, program your local repeaters, simplex calling frequencies and any weather channels your radio can receive. Carry a printed list of frequencies. Repeaters can lose power or be overloaded, so also plan for simplex. Join a local emergency communications group if there is one, so you know how nets and message handling work.
So: which radio do you recommend for a new ham in a mostly-FM area, and is the extra cost of D-STAR or DMR justified before you know your local activity?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10977-choosing-a-first-or-next-handheld-ft-65r-vs-baofeng-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-fits/Share on other sites