Choosing a VHF/UHF antenna: J-pole vs slim jim vs 5/8 whip vs yagi, and where installs usually go wrong
- Replies 2
- Views 50
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing common 2 m / 70 cm antenna options on practical terms: pattern, gain, mounting, feedline and connectors. Many choices get made on advertised gain figures, but the install often matters more than the antenna design. Below is a rough framework. Correct it, add numbers, and say where it doesn't hold.
Quarter-wave whip. At 146 MHz a quarter-wave is roughly 19 to 20 inches, and at 446 MHz roughly 6.5 inches. It is a monopole, so it depends on a ground plane. A car roof works well because it is a large, flat conductor under the element. Gain is modest, and the pattern is omnidirectional in azimuth with a fairly low takeoff angle when mounted on a good ground plane. It is mechanically simple, tolerant of imperfect installs, and often gives a decent match with little tuning.
5/8 wave. A 5/8-wave vertical has a base matching coil and is usually quoted as having a couple of dB more gain than a quarter-wave in ideal conditions. The extra gain comes from a flatter vertical pattern, with more energy toward the horizon. It still depends on the ground plane, and a small or off-center ground plane can distort the pattern and move the SWR. On a vehicle, a 5/8 on a roof center mount is a sensible choice. On a small metal plate, a quarter-wave may behave better than expected.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave designs with a matching section, so they don't need a ground plane the way a quarter-wave does. The weak point is the feedline. If the coax shield isn't isolated, it becomes part of the radiating system and the pattern gets skewed. A few turns of coax as a choke, or ferrite beads, near the feedpoint often improves behavior. A slim jim is essentially a folded J-pole variant. It is often said to give a slightly lower takeoff angle, but the gain should still be treated as roughly dipole-class, not magic. Construction accuracy matters, as does keeping the antenna away from metal masts and gutters.
Collinears. Stacking phased elements squeezes the vertical pattern, which raises gain at the horizon. The tradeoff is vertical beamwidth. A high-gain collinear on a tilted mast, or used where the other station is far above or below you (steep hills, tall buildings), can underperform a lower-gain antenna. Also check how a manufacturer states gain: dBi and dBd differ by about 2.15 dB.
Yagis. A directional antenna adds gain and also rejects signals from other directions, which can help a lot against interference or when working a distant repeater. It needs aiming and a rotator or manual pointing. Polarization must match the intended use: vertical for typical FM repeaters and simplex, horizontal for most weak-signal SSB/CW work.
Coax and connectors. Loss rises quickly with frequency. As approximate figures, small coax such as RG-58 can lose several dB per 100 ft at 146 MHz and noticeably more at 446 MHz. Low-loss types such as LMR-400-class cable lose much less. Check the manufacturer datasheet for the cable you are actually buying. PL-259/SO-239 (UHF) connectors are fine for many VHF runs, but they aren't constant-impedance and are usually avoided at higher UHF frequencies. N-type is constant-impedance, better sealed when installed properly, and the better choice for outdoor 70 cm and up. Weatherproofing matters for either one: water in a coax connector can ruin a good antenna.
Mag mounts and NMO. A magnetic mount is quick and removable, but it needs a clean, flat metal surface, and the coax routing through a door or window seal can be fragile. An NMO mount needs a 3/4 inch hole, but it gives a solid, low-profile, repeatable installation and a proper ground connection. Whichever you use, the roof center is usually the best location.
SWR. A low SWR isn't the same as an efficient antenna. A dummy load is an excellent 1:1 SWR. Lossy coax can also make a bad antenna look better at the radio end, because the reflected power is attenuated on its way back. Measuring at the antenna end with an analyzer is more informative than reading the radio's meter. SWR 2:1 corresponds to about 0.5 dB of mismatch loss, which is less dramatic than many people assume, but with long coax runs at UHF it adds to the existing cable loss.
Polarization and satellites. Cross-polarization between vertical and horizontal antennas can cost on the order of 10 to 20+ dB in practice. That is why handheld use with a tilted radio sounds worse than a roof-mounted vertical. For FM satellites, signals rotate and fade, so circular polarization (crossed yagis, turnstile/eggbeater types) is common for fixed stations. Portable operators often use a handheld two-band yagi and accept some polarization fading. Doppler shift also matters: the downlink frequency drifts during a pass and you retune.
Questions to get the thread going: What are you trying to reach (local repeater, distant repeater, simplex, satellites)? Is the antenna on a vehicle, a mast, or a balcony? Which feedline run are you planning, and at which band do you care most about loss?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10982-choosing-a-vhfuhf-antenna-j-pole-vs-slim-jim-vs-58-whip-vs-yagi-and-where-installs-usually-go-wrong/Share on other sites