Getting started on LEO satellites: FM birds vs. linear, Doppler handling, and whether an Arrow or a rotator-driven Yagi makes sense
- Replies 2
- Views 40
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
This thread is for comparing approaches to a first serious satellite station, covering both FM repeater-type birds and linear transponder birds. Frequencies, tones and satellite health change over time, so check the AMSAT status pages and your tracking program's current TLEs before relying on anything below.
FM birds are the usual entry point. AO-91, AO-92 and SO-50 have been the classic examples, and the ISS has at times carried an APRS digipeater on 145.825 MHz and a voice repeater. They work as single-channel crossband repeaters: one station transmits at a time, the satellite retransmits it, and everyone shares the channel. Some require a CTCSS tone on the uplink, and SO-50 has needed an arming tone before the normal access tone. Operating is mostly short exchanges, usually callsign and four-character grid square, such as FN31. Grid squares matter because many operators collect them as a award or contest-style goal, and you will hear "grid" used as shorthand for the whole exchange.
Doppler is the main technical hurdle. For a LEO pass, radial velocity can approach several km/s, so the shift is about ±3 to 3.5 kHz at 145 MHz and about ±10 kHz at 435 MHz. On FM that is enough to make you sound off-frequency or hard to copy if you ignore it. A common manual method is to start the 70 cm side high at AOS, step down through the pass, and keep the 2 m side adjusted in smaller steps. Gpredict can drive a CAT-capable radio and apply Doppler automatically, and SatPC32 does the same for supported radios and interfaces. Some people prefer manual control for FM because it is simple and forgiving. For SSB and CW it is much more tedious, because a few hundred hertz of error is audible.
Linear transponders are a different style of operating. RS-44 is a well-known example, with an inverting passband on 2 m up and 70 cm down. The satellite takes a slice of spectrum and retransmits all of it, so many stations can work SSB and CW at once. Its higher orbit gives much longer passes than the typical FM bird. Because the transponder is inverting, when you tune your uplink up, your downlink moves down. If your software is set up correctly, you tune one VFO and the program tracks the other, so your signal stays at the same point in the passband. Full duplex is important here. Use headphones so you can hear your own downlink and avoid feedback, and keep transmit power modest, since a strong signal can capture the transponder and push everyone else down.
QO-100 is the odd one out because it is geostationary. There is no Doppler, no tracking, and no pass timing. The narrowband transponder is on 2.4 GHz up and 10.489 GHz down, and its footprint covers Africa, Europe, the Middle East, and parts of South America and Asia. The challenge shifts to dish pointing, LNB frequency stability, and handling microwave RF safely, rather than pass geometry.
On the antenna side, a handheld dual-band Arrow-style Yagi is the usual starting point for portable work, usually with a duplexer or separate radios for 2 m and 70 cm. A fixed station can step up to separate 2 m and 70 cm Yagis on an az/el rotator, often circularly polarized to reduce fading. The rotator brings its own issues: elevation range, cable lengths, and the azimuth swing on near-overhead passes. Prediction software such as Gpredict or SatPC32 can drive it, but it still needs sensible park positions and a clear plan for the 180° flip.
Questions for the thread: what is the lowest-complexity setup that still gives usable results on both FM and linear birds? Is a handheld Arrow plus a CAT-controlled radio a good compromise? And how do you decide when it is worth buying a rotator rather than getting better at manual tracking?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10983-getting-started-on-leo-satellites-fm-birds-vs-linear-doppler-handling-and-whether-an-arrow-or-a-rotator-driven-yagi-makes-sense/Share on other sites