Planning a from-scratch HF wire antenna: where the real compromises are (wire, choke, radials, modeling)
- Replies 2
- Views 51
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'd like to collect notes on building antennas from raw materials instead of buying kits. This is a rough framework for a first multiband wire antenna plus a simple vertical. Please correct it, and add what you'd change.
Wire. For permanent dipoles, 14 AWG hard-drawn copper or copper-clad steel is the usual choice because it resists stretching. Stranded insulated 14 AWG works, but plain copper will sag over time on long spans. Thinner wire (18 to 22 AWG) is fine for portable use and low power, but it breaks more easily. Wire gauge has only a small effect on loss at HF. It affects mechanical life and slightly affects bandwidth and resonant length. Insulation shortens the resonant length by a few percent, so the usual 468/f(MHz) feet is only a starting point. Cut long and trim.
Supports. End insulators can be dogbones, PVC or polycarbonate. Ropes should be UV-resistant polyester or Dyneema-type line, not cheap nylon that stretches. At the center, strain relief matters more than people expect. The coax should not hang from the SO-239 or the wire junction. Use a bracket, or a loop of cable tied to the support.
Feedline and common-mode current. A half-wave dipole is balanced, but coax is not. Without a choke, the coax shield becomes part of the antenna. That distorts the pattern, can bring RF into the shack, and makes SWR readings depend on cable position. A 1:1 current balun at the feedpoint, or a choke of ferrite (mix 31 is common for HF) on the coax, addresses this. A coiled-coax choke is a cheaper alternative, but its bandwidth is narrower. For nonresonant doublets, 450-ohm window line to a tuner with a balun is a good option. Ladder line has low loss even with high SWR, but it wants to stay symmetrical and away from metal.
Verticals. A quarter-wave is roughly 234/f(MHz) feet, trimmed in place. The ground system matters more than the radiator. Elevated resonant radials, two to four of them sloping down, are a practical choice. Ground-mounted verticals need many more radials to reduce loss. Fiberglass poles make good non-conductive supports, but check that a pole is actually fiberglass. Many fishing poles are carbon fiber, which conducts and can detune the wire. It is also a hazard near power lines.
Modeling and measuring. EZNEC (NEC-based) and MMANA-GAL (MININEC-based) are both useful for relative comparisons: height, inverted-V angle, radial count. Check segmentation, ground type, and wire diameter. Treat absolute gain numbers with caution. For measurement, an antenna analyzer gives R and X, not just SWR. The lowest SWR point isn't always resonance, and a reading taken without a choke may change if you touch or move the coax.
Questions for the thread: Are trap antennas worth building at home, or are fan and linked dipoles more reliable? And what's your preferred method for checking whether the choke is working?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11024-planning-a-from-scratch-hf-wire-antenna-where-the-real-compromises-are-wire-choke-radials-modeling/Share on other sites