Small lot, HOA limits, 80–10 m: EFHW vs OCFD vs doublet vs vertical vs loop, and what SWR won't tell you
- Replies 2
- Views 40
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
Here is a common scenario worth working through. The lot is roughly 50 x 100 ft, the HOA bans anything that looks like an antenna, and the operator runs 100 W on SSB and FT8 and wants 40 m through 10 m, with 80 m as a bonus. Which compromise makes the most sense, and what should you measure before judging it?
These are the candidates, with the tradeoffs I'd put on the table.
End-fed half-wave (EFHW). A 49:1 or 64:1 transformer at the end of a half-wave wire (about 66 ft cut for 40 m) gives you 40/20/15/10 on harmonics with no tuner. It is easy to hang as a sloper or inverted L, and one support is enough. The catches are that the feedpoint impedance is in the thousands of ohms, so transformer losses and core heating matter. There is also no true counterpoise, so the coax shield becomes part of the antenna unless you add a choke or a counterpoise wire. A common-mode choke a short distance down the coax is cheap insurance. Harmonic bands are not perfectly resonant either, so expect some bands to need a short tuner assist or trimming.
Off-center fed dipole (OCFD / Windom style). Feeding at roughly the 1/3 point with a 4:1 current balun gives a workable match on several bands from one wire. The feedpoint can be fed with ordinary coax, which is simpler than the EFHW, but the balun has to cope with different impedances per band, and the radiation patterns get lobey on the higher bands. A choke on the coax is still a good idea.
G5RV and other doublets. A G5RV is a 102 ft flat-top with a 31 ft ladder-line section into coax. It is really a 20 m 3/2-wavelength design, and on other bands it relies on a tuner. A plain doublet (any reasonably long flat-top, balanced line, tuner) does the same job with fewer assumptions. Its strength is that ladder line has very low loss even at high SWR, so the antenna works across 80–10 m. The weakness is routing a balanced line through a small yard and into the shack without letting it run close to metal.
Inverted V. Needs just one mast, and the center can be high while the ends droop toward the ground. The resonant length is a few percent longer than the same wire flat, and feedpoint impedance drops toward 50 ohms as the included angle narrows (around 90–120° is common). Keep the ends well out of reach, since they carry high voltage.
Verticals and loops. A ground-mounted vertical needs a radial field. Many short radials beat a few long ones, and ground-mounted systems commonly use 16 or more. Elevated radials resonant at 1/4 wave work with far fewer (often 2–4 per band), but the system gets bigger and more visible. A magnetic loop is small enough to hide, but it is narrow-band and needs retuning when you move a few kHz. Its efficiency depends heavily on conductor size, the quality of the capacitor and joints, and where you place it.
The thing I'd most like to discuss is how to evaluate these. SWR tells you how well the transmitter is matched to the feedline, not how much power is radiated. A dummy load is a perfect 1:1. So what do you trust: a NanoVNA, a field strength check, WSPR or RBN comparisons, or something else?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11057-small-lot-hoa-limits-8010-m-efhw-vs-ocfd-vs-doublet-vs-vertical-vs-loop-and-what-swr-wont-tell-you/Share on other sites