Planning a multi-day field comms deployment: generator vs. LiFePO4 vs. solar, and where noise and grounding bite
- Replies 2
- Views 39
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
I'd like to compare approaches to a power and antenna plan for a deployment of 24 to 72 hours, such as an EMCOMM shelter support role, a served-agency backup link, or an event with no reliable mains. The goal is a station that stays quiet on receive, doesn't need constant attention, and can be torn down in the dark if it has to be.
Start with a power budget before choosing hardware. Write down each load, its current at 12-13.8 V, and a realistic duty cycle. An HF rig at 100 W on SSB can pull around 20 A on peaks, but average draw over an hour of mostly listening is far lower. Receive current on an HF or VHF/UHF rig is often only 1 to 2 A. Add the laptop, a digital-mode interface, lighting, a charger bank for handhelds, and any router or hotspot. Multiply by hours and add margin. A made-up example: 8 A average for 12 hours is about 96 Ah, which is nearly a full 100 Ah LiFePO4 battery if you keep any reserve. That is why "one battery and a small panel" often looks fine on paper and falls short by the second night.
LiFePO4 is attractive because the voltage stays flat. A nominal 12.8 V pack sits near 13.2-13.3 V under moderate load for most of its capacity, which suits radios designed for 13.8 V. Check three things on a pack: the continuous current rating of the BMS, whether it has low-temperature charge protection (charging below freezing can permanently damage cells), and what the pack does at cutoff. Some BMS units disconnect abruptly, and that drops a radio mid-transmission. Put a fuse close to the battery, use a common Powerpole orientation across the group, and size the wire for voltage drop at peak current, not average.
For charging, an inverter generator is the fast, predictable source. Solar is the quiet one, but it only helps if the array is sized for the weather you might get. An MPPT controller with a LiFePO4 profile is usually worth it over PWM, but cheap controllers can be real HF noise sources. Test the controller with the radio before deployment, not at the site. A DC-DC charger from a vehicle is another option, but treat it as a noise source too.
Questions for the group: Do you run the generator continuously, or cycle it to charge the battery and then shut down for quiet receive windows? How much separation do you plan between the generator, the operating position, and the antenna? And what is your minimum viable antenna for a regional NVIS link, given that a 33 ft fiberglass mast and a low inverted-V or dipole can be quick to raise but need guying and clearance from power lines?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11084-planning-a-multi-day-field-comms-deployment-generator-vs-lifepo4-vs-solar-and-where-noise-and-grounding-bite/Share on other sites