Choosing a handheld: Baofeng vs FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75, plus what to sort out before an emergency
- Replies 2
- Views 43
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Starting point for a general HT discussion: what should a handheld actually do for you, and which radios fit which job? Features, batteries, antennas, programming and emergency readiness all matter more than a spec sheet suggests.
Budget analog dual-banders. The Baofeng UV-5R family and the Yaesu FT-65R cover 2 m (144 MHz) and 70 cm (430 MHz) FM at around 5 W. Both are analog FM only, which is what most local repeaters and simplex activity use. The usual argument for the Yaesu is a more conventional receiver and a more established brand. The argument for Baofeng is price, and it's easy to buy a spare. Cheap radios vary in receiver selectivity and transmit cleanliness, so check the specific model and don't assume every cheap radio is equivalent. Keep in mind that a licence is required to transmit on amateur frequencies, and that rules on equipment differ by country.
D-STAR and multimode. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band handheld that does analog FM plus D-STAR digital voice, with GPS and Bluetooth. The Kenwood TH-D75 also does D-STAR and FM, adds 222 MHz coverage in the tri-band version sold in some regions, and has built-in APRS capability. Both are worth it if D-STAR is active where you are, or if you want GPS position and APRS. They cost several times what an analog HT does, and they are only as useful as your local network.
The IC-705 is a different animal. It gets lumped in with handhelds, but it's a portable HF/VHF/UHF all-mode transceiver, with D-STAR on the VHF/UHF side. It isn't a pocket HT. It makes sense as a go-kit or portable HF rig that can also do VHF/UHF, not as a replacement for a handheld on your belt.
DMR. DMR handhelds are a separate decision from the radios above, because DMR depends on the network around it. You need a DMR ID (registered through RadioID.net), a codeplug with the right color codes, timeslots and talkgroups, and a repeater that carries what you want. DMR radios are also typically more demanding to program than analog ones. Check that local DMR repeaters are active before buying one.
Batteries. Most modern HTs use Li-ion packs, so the practical advice is simple: buy at least one spare, and ideally a pack or case that takes AA cells as a backup. Know how long your radio really lasts with a mix of receive, standby and transmit, not just the rated figure. Low power on simplex and repeater work saves a lot of runtime.
Antennas. The stock rubber duck is a compromise on both bands. A longer telescoping whip or a roll-up J-pole often gets you further than any radio upgrade. Check the connector first, since SMA-male and SMA-female ends differ between radios, and swapping to a better antenna only helps if it is properly matched for the band you use.
Programming with CHIRP. CHIRP is free, open-source software for programming many radios. Always download the current configuration from the radio first and save that image before you edit anything. Then enter or import your repeaters, for example from a RepeaterBook export. Supported models and cable requirements vary, so check the CHIRP supported radios list before assuming your model works. A bad programming cable (some clones use unreliable chipsets) is a common cause of failed uploads.
Repeater offsets. In the US, 2 m repeaters usually use a ±600 kHz offset and 70 cm repeaters use ±5 MHz, with 1.25 m typically −1.6 MHz. Other countries use different offsets, so confirm locally. You also need the correct CTCSS (PL) tone to access many repeaters. Some radios apply standard offsets automatically but not always correctly, so verify them against a repeater directory.
Emergency use. A handheld is only part of a plan. Program local repeaters, simplex frequencies (in the US, 146.520 MHz is the 2 m national calling frequency), and any local emergency-net frequencies ahead of time, and keep a paper copy of the list. Repeaters can lose power or go off the air, so know your simplex options. Follow your local emergency communications organisation's procedures rather than improvising, and practice using the radio before you need it.
Questions for discussion: which features do you consider essential, which do you think are overrated, and how do you decide between a cheap spare HT and one nicer radio?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11096-choosing-a-handheld-baofeng-vs-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-plus-what-to-sort-out-before-an-emergency/Share on other sites