Planning a dual-band mobile install: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, wiring, noise and etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 35
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'm putting together a checklist for people setting up their first 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile, and I'd like the group's input before it gets finalized. The three rigs that come up most are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. All three are dual-band FM mobiles in the 50 W class, but they differ in features, and the differences affect how you install and use them.
Radio choice. The FTM-500D is Yaesu's System Fusion (C4FM) radio and also handles analog FM. The ID-5100A is Icom's D-STAR radio with a large touchscreen. The TM-D710G is an analog FM radio with a built-in TNC and GPS for APRS, and it is the one usually mentioned when people ask about cross-band repeat. Feature sets change by model and firmware, so check each manual rather than trusting a forum summary, mine included. If you only use analog repeaters and simplex, the digital modes may not matter. If your local repeaters are mostly Fusion or D-STAR, that decides it quickly.
Cross-band repeat. Cross-band repeat means the mobile receives on one band and retransmits on the other, for example receiving a handheld on 70 cm and retransmitting on 2 m. It is useful for extending a handheld's reach from a vehicle, but you are operating a station that retransmits, so check your local rules on control operator responsibility and station identification. Also check that your specific radio supports it before you buy.
Mounting. Keep the body where the cables reach and air can move around it, and keep it clear of airbags and the driver's knee zone. The control head should be where you can use it without taking your eyes off the road for more than a glance. A separable head is handy in cramped dashboards, but check what cable or kit your model needs. Mic placement matters as much as head placement, because you should be able to reach the mic without searching for it.
Power and fusing. The usual advice is to run power directly to the battery, not to a cigarette lighter socket or a random accessory circuit. Put the fuse holder close to the positive battery terminal, use the wire gauge the manual specifies, and protect the cable with a grommet where it passes through the firewall. Fuse the positive lead at the rating the manufacturer recommends. Many manufacturers supply fused cables with a fuse on each lead. On newer vehicles with a battery monitoring sensor on the negative post, check the service information before attaching anything to the negative terminal.
Antenna and coax. The antenna is the largest factor in mobile performance. A center-roof NMO mount with a dual-band whip is a standard approach, and a magnetic mount can work as a temporary option. Cable loss is higher on 70 cm than on 2 m, so use quality coax and avoid unnecessarily long runs. Check SWR on both bands, not just one.
Noise. Noise sources include alternator whine, ignition noise, LED lighting, DC-DC converters and charging systems. Check with the engine off, then running, then with accessories switched on and off one at a time. Open the squelch to find the noise. Common fixes include moving power and coax away from each other, improving the ground, and adding ferrite chokes where appropriate. Fix the cause first and filter second.
Etiquette. Keep mobile operating safe and legal: know your local rules on handheld mic use and distraction, and don't make long calls in traffic. Keep transmissions brief, identify properly, and say you're mobile if signal drops or you need to pause. On digital modes, wait a moment before replying to allow for network delay. Leave room for others to break in, especially on busy repeaters.
What would you add or change? In particular, I'd like opinions on whether new mobile operators should choose their radio by repeater mode, by cross-band repeat, or by control head layout.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11123-planning-a-dual-band-mobile-install-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-wiring-noise-and-etiquette/Share on other sites