Small lot and HOA-sensitive HF: EFHW, OCFD, doublet or vertical, and where the loss actually hides
- Replies 2
- Views 28
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Here is a scenario to pick apart. Take a typical suburban lot, roughly 60 x 100 ft, with one tree or a 25-30 ft mast that could pass as a flagpole. Power is 100 W, and the bands of interest are 40 and 20 m for most operating, 80 m now and then, and 15/10 m when they open. There is no tower, and anything bulky draws attention. How would you rank the realistic choices?
The candidates are an end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer, an off-center fed dipole (OCFD), a G5RV, a center-fed doublet on ladder line with a tuner, an inverted V, a ground-mounted or elevated-radial vertical, and a small magnetic loop. It is easy to argue about which one has the lowest SWR. That is mostly the wrong measurement, since SWR only tells you how well the load matches the line, not how much power is radiated. A dummy load has a perfect SWR and zero gain.
The places where power gets lost or where patterns go wrong are more useful to compare:
1. Matching network loss. This covers transformer core heating in EFHW and OCFD units, trap loss, and tuner loss into a high-impedance load.
2. Feedline loss at a high SWR. Coax loss is small when matched, but it rises when the SWR is high, and thin coax on the upper bands is the usual culprit.
3. Common-mode current. The coax shield becomes part of the antenna. This distorts the pattern and brings RF into the shack, and it is the usual cause of readings that change when you touch the cable.
4. Ground loss. For verticals, this is often the biggest factor.
5. Height. Roughly, a horizontal wire at 0.5 wavelength gives useful low-angle radiation, while one below about 0.2 wavelength behaves more like a high-angle (NVIS-style) antenna. At 30 ft, that is about 0.21 wavelength on 40 m, which is fine for regional work and mediocre for DX, but about 0.44 wavelength on 20 m, which is much better.
Which of these matter most for a lot like this, and which antenna would you pick if you could only put up one?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11140-small-lot-and-hoa-sensitive-hf-efhw-ocfd-doublet-or-vertical-and-where-the-loss-actually-hides/Share on other sites