Digital modes toolchain: choosing between FT8, FT4, JS8Call, PSK31, RTTY, WSPR, Q65 and MSK144, and where setups usually break
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Mike 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Digital operating is really two problems stacked together. The first is picking a mode that fits the path and the goal. The second is making the station behave: audio levels, CAT, and a clock that is actually right. Most "the software is broken" threads turn out to be the second problem.
Rough mode map. FT8 uses 15-second T/R periods, 8-GFSK, and about 50 Hz of occupied bandwidth. Its decode threshold is around -20 dB SNR, referenced to a 2500 Hz noise bandwidth. FT4 is faster (7.5 s periods, roughly 80 Hz wide) and gives up a few dB of sensitivity, which makes it better suited to contest-style exchanges. WSPR is a beacon mode with 2-minute transmissions and a very narrow signal. Its threshold is around -30 dB, so it is a propagation tool rather than a QSO mode. Q65 has several T/R period and tone-spacing submodes and is aimed at hard paths such as EME, tropo and ionospheric scatter. MSK144 is built for meteor-scatter pings, where the usable signal may last only a fraction of a second.
JS8Call borrows FT8-style modulation but adds free-form keyboard messaging, relaying and store-and-forward. Its speed settings trade throughput for sensitivity. Older keyboard modes are still useful: PSK31 (31.25 baud, very narrow, but weak against fading and QRM), RTTY (45.45 baud, 170 Hz shift, the standard in contests), Olivia and other MFSK variants (strong forward error correction, slow, good in poor conditions), and Hellschreiber (readable by eye, which is its oddity and its charm). Winlink is a different animal. It is message transport rather than a chat mode, using gateways and modems such as VARA, ARDOP or Pactor. VARA is proprietary, and its free version is speed-limited.
Questions to get the thread going:
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11156-digital-modes-toolchain-choosing-between-ft8-ft4-js8call-psk31-rtty-wspr-q65-and-msk144-and-where-setups-usually-break/Share on other sites