Choosing a handheld: budget FM, D-STAR, DMR, or something like the IC-705? Features, batteries, antennas and CHIRP tips
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
Handheld choice gets confusing fast, because the radios people mention together are very different tools. A Baofeng or a Yaesu FT-65R is a simple analog FM dual-bander. An Icom ID-52A or Kenwood TH-D75 adds D-STAR, GPS and APRS-style features. The IC-705 is a portable multiband rig, not a pocket HT, and it makes sense only if you want HF or SSB. DMR handhelds are a separate group again. I'd like to sort out what actually matters before buying.
Analog dual-band basics. Most people start with a 144/430 MHz FM handheld. Check how easy it is to scan, store memories, set tones and reverse the repeater input. The FT-65R is a common recommendation for a straightforward 5 W analog radio. Budget radios in the Baofeng class cost less and have lots of features, but many have weaker receiver selectivity and spurious-emission performance than better-engineered radios. In a busy RF area, that can mean overload from strong nearby signals. If you do buy one, keep your power sensible and know exactly what frequencies you are programming.
D-STAR and DMR. D-STAR on the ID-52A or TH-D75 needs a local D-STAR repeater or hotspot, and you must register your callsign with the D-STAR network to use gateway features. DMR needs a DMR ID, a codeplug with the right color code, time slot and talkgroups, and usually the manufacturer's software rather than CHIRP. Neither mode is useful if nothing on your side of town supports it, so check local repeater coverage first.
Batteries, antennas, repeaters and emergencies. A spare battery matters more than an extra feature. A battery case that takes AA cells is useful backup if your radio has one available. The stock rubber duck is a compromise, and a longer quarter-wave whip or a roll-up J-pole often improves things noticeably. Check the connector gender on your radio before ordering, since SMA-male and SMA-female are easy to mix up. Remember also that a good antenna on a low-power radio does more than extra power on a poor one.
For repeaters, do not rely on memory for offsets. Common US 2 m offsets are plus or minus 600 kHz and 70 cm is usually plus or minus 5 MHz, but local band plans vary, and some systems need CTCSS or DCS tones. Use a current local repeater directory or your club's list. For emergency use, learn simplex first, because repeaters can go down. Practice with your local ARES/club net, and carry a written frequency list in case the radio is reset.
What are you actually trying to do: casual local repeaters, digital modes, hiking, or emergency communication? That changes which of these radios makes sense.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11182-choosing-a-handheld-budget-fm-d-star-dmr-or-something-like-the-ic-705-features-batteries-antennas-and-chirp-tips/Share on other sites