2 m/70 cm antenna choices: J-pole vs slim jim vs 5/8 wave vs yagi, and how much the coax and connectors matter
- Replies 2
- Views 27
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
I'd like to start a technical thread on VHF/UHF antenna selection, because the same questions come up whether the use is a home base station, a mobile install, a repeater site or a satellite pass. The antenna is only one part of the system. Coax loss, connector choice, polarization and mounting often decide how well a setup works more than a couple of dB of advertised gain.
Start with the simple verticals. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches long on 2 m (roughly 234 divided by the frequency in MHz gives feet) and about 6 to 6.5 inches on 70 cm. It needs a ground plane, which on a vehicle is the roof. It has a low-angle, omnidirectional pattern and is mechanically simple. A 5/8 wave whip is taller and, with a matching coil at the base, concentrates more energy toward the horizon. That gives a few dB more at low angles than a quarter-wave over a good ground plane, but it is more dependent on that ground plane, and the gain is less if the ground is poor or the roof is small. On a mag mount, the base couples to the metal body capacitively. It works well on a steel roof but poorly on aluminum, fiberglass or a tiny trunk lid. NMO mounts need a drilled hole, but the result is a solid ground connection and a mount that can take many different whips.
The J-pole and slim jim are both end-fed half-wave verticals. The J-pole uses a quarter-wave matching stub, and the slim jim is a folded variation of the same idea. They are popular because they are cheap to build from ladder line, copper pipe or twin-lead. Their gain is roughly that of a half-wave dipole, and the vertical element is omnidirectional on the horizon. The weak point of both is common-mode current on the feedline. Without a choke or decoupling section just below the feedpoint, the coax shield becomes part of the antenna. That distorts the pattern, can shift the SWR when you move the cable, and sometimes puts RF into the shack. An open-air J-pole with a few turns of coax or a ferrite choke is a different antenna from one with the coax draped against the mast.
Collinear antennas stack phased elements to narrow the elevation pattern. The gain is gained by flattening the beam, not by adding energy. Typical commercial collinears for 2 m or dual-band use give anywhere from about 3 to 9 dBi depending on length. A tall high-gain collinear can be excellent for flat terrain and distant stations. In hilly country or at close range it can send too little signal downhill, so a shorter, lower-gain antenna may work better for local coverage.
Yagis are directional, with typical gains of about 6 to 12 dBi for a practical-size beam. They help with a weak repeater, a distant simplex contact or terrestrial weak-signal work. Polarization matters here. FM voice and repeater work on VHF/UHF is almost always vertical. SSB and CW weak-signal work is conventionally horizontal. Mismatching polarization costs a lot of signal, often 10 to 20 dB or more in practice. For satellite work, linear antennas will see fading as the satellite tumbles or changes orientation relative to you. Circular polarization such as crossed yagis, a turnstile or a helix avoids most of that, but many FM LEO operators get by with a handheld yagi and a handheld or mobile radio, adjusting the antenna angle during the pass.
On the feedline side, coax loss rises quickly with frequency. Approximate figures per 100 ft: RG-58 is around 4.5 dB at 150 MHz and about 8 dB or more at 450 MHz; RG-8X is somewhat better; and low-loss 400-class coax is about 1.5 dB at 150 MHz and about 2.7 dB at 450 MHz. Check the exact datasheet for any cable you buy. A 6 dB gain antenna on 100 ft of RG-58 at UHF can lose most of its advantage to the cable. Connector choice matters too. The PL-259/SO-239 (the 'UHF' connector) is common, cheap and fine on HF and 2 m for modest power. It does not hold a constant impedance and is not weatherproof by design, so it is less appealing on 70 cm and up. The N-type is a constant-impedance, better-sealed connector that is a standard choice for outdoor VHF/UHF, repeater work and anything higher in frequency.
SWR is the last piece that gets misread. It tells you how well the antenna impedance matches the line, not how well the antenna radiates. A dummy load has an excellent SWR and radiates nothing. Lossy coax also improves the SWR you read at the radio, because reflected power gets attenuated on the way back. If possible, measure SWR at the antenna end or with a short test jumper, and then compare it with the reading through the full run. A significant difference points to loss in the cable or a bad connector.
For repeater work, vertical polarization and a good height above average terrain generally matter more than raw gain. Duplexers and antenna spacing handle transmit/receive isolation. For installation in general, keep vertical antennas off to the side of a mast, not directly on top of a metal pole, weatherproof every outdoor connector, use drip loops, and ground the mast and coax properly for lightning protection.
My questions for the thread: which of these tradeoffs have you found most important when choosing between a J-pole, a collinear and a beam? When do you go straight to N-type, and when does it still make sense to use PL-259 on 2 m? And for satellite work, is a handheld Arrow-style yagi enough, or is it worth moving to a fixed circularly polarized setup?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11187-2-m70-cm-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-slim-jim-vs-58-wave-vs-yagi-and-how-much-the-coax-and-connectors-matter/Share on other sites