Starting EME: what each band really demands (2 m, 70 cm, 23 cm, 10 GHz), JT65 vs Q65, and how to plan a first sked
- Replies 2
- Views 36
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
This thread is meant as a practical starting point for comparing the bands and for discussing where a first moonbounce station should put its effort. The figures below are rough planning numbers, not a design spec. Check them against your own antenna data and local power rules.
Start with the path. Round-trip loss to the Moon is very roughly 252 dB on 144 MHz, 261 to 262 dB on 432 MHz, 271 dB on 1296 MHz and close to 290 dB on 10 GHz. Antenna gain on each end offsets most of that. Because EME loss follows the fourth power of distance, the swing between perigee and apogee is about 2 dB, so the same station is noticeably easier at perigee. Moon declination, sky noise behind the Moon and your own horizon matter as much as raw power.
On 2 m, the usual entry point is an array of several long-boom Yagis (four is a common minimum, more is better) with power in the several-hundred-watt to legal-limit range. Sky and galactic noise are high on this band, so an extremely low noise figure buys less than it does higher up, and the Moon position relative to the galactic plane changes your noise floor a lot. Beamwidth is wide enough that tracking is forgiving, and many arrays can be elevation-steered. The cost is the big mechanical structure and the polarization problem described below.
On 70 cm, expect to use four or more long Yagis, a larger Yagi group, or a dish. Gain per square metre is higher, the structures are smaller, and Faraday rotation is much less of a nuisance. Pointing precision starts to matter, and Doppler and spread are bigger than on 2 m.
On 23 cm, dishes dominate. For scale, a 3 m dish at 1296 MHz with decent efficiency is roughly 30 dBi, with a beamwidth near 5 degrees. A 4 m or larger dish is a noticeable step up. At this point receiver noise matters. Low-loss feed lines, a mast- or feed-mounted LNA with very low noise figure, and careful T/R sequencing are required, because a few tenths of a dB lost ahead of the preamp are straight lost signal. Linear and circular polarization are both used, so check the convention with your partner. After reflection the circular sense reverses, which is why the common arrangement is to transmit one sense and receive the opposite.
On 10 GHz, a 3 m dish gives roughly 47 dBi but has a beamwidth well under a degree, which is about the size of the Moon itself. Surface accuracy, feed placement, mechanical stiffness, tracking accuracy and wind loading become the real project. Doppler shift and Doppler spread are large, so JT65C-type tone spacing (or the Q65 submode recommended for the band) is used instead of the narrower choices that suit 2 m.
On modes: JT65 has long been the standard for weak-signal EME, with JT65A common on 2 m, JT65B on 70 cm and 23 cm, and JT65C on the microwave bands. Q65 in current WSJT-X releases is the newer option, designed to work well with fading and Doppler spread, and it can give a dB or two of improvement in some conditions. Both use one-minute T/R periods and compact shorthand messages for the end of the QSO. Check the current WSJT-X documentation and the activity on your band before choosing a submode, because 60 A to 60 D are matched to spread, which grows with frequency.
Libration fading is the rocking motion of the Moon, which spreads the echo in Doppler and makes the signal flutter. It scales roughly with frequency, from a very small effect on 2 m to a major one on microwaves. It is one reason wider tone spacing is used on the higher bands, and it is why you may see an echo that is strong but not decodable.
Questions for the group. Which band is the best use of a limited budget for someone starting from nothing? How much of the plan should go into tracking and preamp quality compared with antenna size? What is the simplest way to verify the station before the first sked: Sun and Moon noise measurements, own echoes in the WSJT-X Echo tool, or listening for a known big station?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11194-starting-eme-what-each-band-really-demands-2-m-70-cm-23-cm-10-ghz-jt65-vs-q65-and-how-to-plan-a-first-sked/Share on other sites