VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole vs 5/8 whip vs collinear vs yagi, and where coax, connectors and SWR fit in
- Replies 2
- Views 49
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
This thread is for sorting out what matters when you pick and install a VHF/UHF antenna. Most of the arguments come from mixing up gain, pattern, feedline loss and mounting, so here is a baseline to push back on.
Start with the basic omni antennas. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches long on 2 m and roughly 6.5 inches on 70 cm. It needs a ground plane, such as a vehicle roof or a set of radials, and it has a fairly low-angle pattern with roughly unity gain over a ground-plane reference. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and usually has a loading coil or matching network at the base. It concentrates a bit more energy toward the horizon, and the commonly quoted benefit is a few dB over a quarter-wave. That figure depends heavily on the ground plane, and a 5/8 wave on a small or off-center ground plane can disappoint.
The J-pole and slim jim are both end-fed half-wave antennas with a quarter-wave matching section. They are easy to build and tolerate rough conditions, but their gain is about that of a half-wave dipole, so don't expect big numbers from the shape alone. Because they have no true radial system, the outside of the coax can become part of the antenna. A choke or a few ferrite beads, or coiling the coax into a choke near the feedpoint, can keep the pattern from getting distorted.
Collinears stack phased half-wave sections to squash the vertical pattern. This gives more gain toward the horizon, but the beam gets narrower in elevation. That is great for a flat-terrain repeater or a base station talking to distant stations. It can be worse if you are on a hill and want to reach stations well below you. Keep any collinear well clear of the mast, because a metal mast right next to the radiating elements will distort the pattern.
Yagis are the right choice when you know where the other station is. A few elements give a good improvement over an omni, and long-boom designs go further. Keep dBd and dBi straight, because they differ by 2.15 dB. A manufacturer quoting dBi will look about 2 dB better than the same antenna quoted in dBd.
So the questions for discussion: when would you pick a gain omni over a small yagi on a fixed station, and which of these antennas do you think are most often oversold on their gain?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11217-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-58-whip-vs-collinear-vs-yagi-and-where-coax-connectors-and-swr-fit-in/Share on other sites