Small lot, HOA, one band or many: which compromise HF wire antenna gives the best return? EFHW vs OCFD vs G5RV vs doublet
- Replies 2
- Views 33
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Here is a scenario that comes up constantly on the forums. A ham has a suburban lot, a roughly 60 to 70 ft run for a wire, one or two supports around 25 to 35 ft, and an HOA that frowns on anything that looks like a tower. There is no room for a beam. They want 80 or 40 through 10 m, a transceiver with an internal tuner, and minimal fuss. Which wire antenna do you pick, and why?
Let's compare the usual candidates on what they actually do, not just on what the SWR meter shows.
End-fed half-wave (EFHW). The feedpoint is at the end of a half-wave wire, where impedance is very high (a few thousand ohms). A 49:1 or 64:1 transformer brings it down to something a transmitter can use. A wire cut for 40 m also works on 20, 15 and 10 m because those are harmonics. The weak point is that there is no true balanced feed. The coax shield and the transformer case act as part of the antenna, so a poor common-mode choke or a feedline that happens to be a bad length can change the SWR and the noise level. The wire is also high voltage at the end, so keep it out of reach of people and pets.
Off-center-fed dipole (OCFD). This is a half-wave wire fed about a third of the way along, typically through a 4:1 current balun. It gives usable multi-band coverage on 80/40/20/10 m with odd patterns on some bands. It is a better-balanced system than an EFHW, but the match is only approximate, and you still need good choking at the feedpoint.
G5RV. This is a roughly 102 ft flat-top with about 34 ft of ladder line, then coax to the shack. It was designed around 20 m, where the antenna is about 3/2 wavelength, and elsewhere it is a tuner-assisted compromise. It works, but the coax often sees a high SWR on bands other than 20 m, and that costs you loss, especially if you use thin coax on the higher bands.
Doublet with open-wire or ladder line. A center-fed wire, ideally not an awkward length, with balanced line to an external tuner or a balun/tuner combination. It is the most flexible and typically the lowest-loss option on many bands, because balanced line loses very little even with a high SWR. The downside is routing: ladder line does not like to touch metal gutters or run close parallel to other conductors, and it has to come into the shack somewhere.
Inverted V. If you have one tall support, this is the easy way to get a dipole on the air. The ends droop, so the resonant length is a few percent shorter, and bandwidth and feedpoint impedance shift (usually toward 50 ohms, which is convenient). Try to keep the included angle at 90 degrees or more and keep the ends well above head height.
Two things I would like this thread to dig into. First, SWR is not efficiency. A dummy load is perfectly 1:1. What matters is radiation, feedline and transformer loss, and ground loss. Second, height above ground: a horizontal dipole below about a quarter wavelength tends to send more energy upward. That is fine for regional contacts on 40 or 80 m, but not what you want for DX on the higher bands.
What would you string up in this lot, and what would you measure to decide whether it is working?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11228-small-lot-hoa-one-band-or-many-which-compromise-hf-wire-antenna-gives-the-best-return-efhw-vs-ocfd-vs-g5rv-vs-doublet/Share on other sites