Choosing an HT: FM-only budget radios vs. D-STAR and DMR handhelds, plus the setup basics that matter more than the model
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Handheld pricing runs from very cheap FM-only dual banders to multimode digital radios that cost many times as much, so it's worth sorting out what each tier gets you. This thread is for comparing notes on features, batteries, antennas, programming and emergency use. Corrections and local differences are welcome.
Budget analog dual banders. The Baofeng UV-5R family and the Yaesu FT-65R both cover 2 m and 70 cm FM at about 5 W or less. The Baofengs are very cheap and have a huge accessory ecosystem. The usual complaints are weak receiver selectivity (strong nearby signals can overload it), mediocre transmit spectral purity, and menus that are hard to learn. The FT-65R costs more but is generally seen as a step up in receiver performance and build quality, with a more straightforward interface. Both are analog FM only, which covers most local repeater and simplex activity. Check the current firmware, specs and regulatory status of whatever model you actually buy, because these change between revisions.
D-STAR handhelds. The Icom ID-52A and the Kenwood TH-D75 both do FM and D-STAR digital voice. The ID-52A is a 2 m/70 cm radio with GPS and Bluetooth. The TH-D75 adds 220 MHz coverage in North American versions, with built-in APRS and GPS logging. D-STAR is only useful if there's a D-STAR repeater or reflector you can reach, so look at your area's coverage before paying extra for it. You'll also need to register a callsign for D-STAR, and the radio's call-sign routing settings take some time to understand.
The IC-705 is a different kind of radio. It often shows up in handheld discussions, but it's a portable all-mode transceiver covering HF, 6 m, 2 m and 70 cm, not an HT. It supports SSB, CW and D-STAR, and it makes sense if you want portable HF/QRP work (parks, summits) as well as VHF/UHF. It's bulkier and needs a proper antenna setup, so it doesn't replace a pocketable HT for carrying around or for quick repeater access.
DMR. DMR handhelds from vendors like AnyTone, Radioddity and TYT are popular and relatively inexpensive. They require a DMR ID, a codeplug containing talkgroups, color codes and time slots, and some patience. CHIRP is mainly aimed at analog FM programming. For DMR you'll typically use the manufacturer's CPS or a community firmware tool. Like D-STAR, DMR only pays off if local digital repeaters are active.
Programming with CHIRP. A few habits save trouble. Download the existing configuration from the radio first and save that image file as a backup. Use a decent programming cable, since cheap cables with counterfeit USB chips can cause driver headaches. Import repeater lists from a source like RepeaterBook, then check frequency, offset, tone mode and tone values rather than trusting the import blindly. Use clear names (callsign or location, not just a number), and keep a separate memory block for simplex, weather and emergency channels.
Offsets and tones. In the US, the common conventions are ±600 kHz on 2 m and ±5 MHz on 70 cm, with the direction depending on the sub-band and local coordination. Other countries and regions use different splits (many places use a different 70 cm shift), so always check your local band plan and repeater directory. Many repeaters need a CTCSS tone on transmit; "Tone" encodes only, while "TSQL" also mutes your receiver until the tone is heard. Not every repeater uses the same tone on input and output, so verify both.
Batteries and antennas. Most HTs ship with a single Li-ion pack, and one spare is worth having, especially for event support. If you won't use a pack for weeks, store it partly charged rather than full. Many people find that the stock rubber duck is a major limit on range, and a longer 1/4-wave or 5/8-wave whip often improves things noticeably. Make sure the connector matches (SMA-female vs. SMA-male conventions vary, and some radios use BNC), and avoid transmitting without an antenna attached. For serious range, a roll-up J-pole or small Yagi on a mast beats any rubber duck.
Emergency use. A radio is only helpful if you've set it up beforehand. Program local repeaters, the simplex calling frequencies for your region, NOAA/weather channels where available, and any frequencies your local emergency group uses. Keep a paper copy of the channel list. Remember that a licence is required for amateur transmit, and that wideband receive capability does not mean you may transmit outside the amateur bands. Consider using low power when a nearby station is within range, to save battery.
What would you point a newcomer toward as a first HT, and is paying extra for digital modes worth it for someone who mostly wants local repeater and emergency use?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11251-choosing-an-ht-fm-only-budget-radios-vs-d-star-and-dmr-handhelds-plus-the-setup-basics-that-matter-more-than-the-model/Share on other sites