Dual-band mobile rigs compared: FTM-500D, ID-5100A and TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Many people putting a 2 meter / 70 centimeter radio in a vehicle are choosing between three well-known 50-watt class dual-band mobiles: the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. They overlap a lot, but they lean toward different kinds of operating. This thread is for comparing them and for the less glamorous parts of a good mobile: power wiring, fusing, antenna mounting, noise and on-air manners.
Starting points for discussion:
Which radio fits which style. The FTM-500D is built around Yaesu's C4FM digital mode with analog FM, and it is the one to look at if your local repeaters or WIRES-X rooms use that system. The ID-5100A is the D-STAR choice, with a large touchscreen and a focus on digital voice and GPS-linked features. The TM-D710G is an analog FM radio with built-in APRS and a TNC, which makes it attractive if you want position reporting and messaging without an external tracker. Before choosing on specs, find out which modes your local repeaters actually use. A radio with a mode nobody around you uses is just an expensive analog rig.
Cross-band repeat. Among these three, the TM-D710G is the one commonly associated with a cross-band repeat function, which lets you use a handheld on one band and have the mobile retransmit on the other. Check the manual for your exact model and firmware before counting on this for any of them. Also remember that you are still the control operator. Know your licence class privileges, ID properly, and don't leave a cross-band repeat running unattended where it could cause interference.
Power and fusing. A 50-watt FM mobile can pull on the order of 10 to 12 amps or more on high power transmit, so the cigarette-lighter socket is the wrong source. The supplied power cable normally has fuses in line on the positive lead, and those fuses belong close to the battery, not near the radio. If you extend the cable, use wire at least as heavy as the original, keep joints crimped and soldered or otherwise properly made, and don't replace a fuse with a larger one just to stop it blowing. A blown fuse is telling you something. On newer vehicles, especially ones with battery current sensors or start-stop systems, check the manufacturer's guidance on where to connect the negative lead. Hybrids and EVs have their own 12 V access points and cautions.
Mounting. The radio body needs a secure spot where it won't become a projectile or block airbag deployment. The control head or face should be where you can see it without taking your eyes off the road for more than a glance. Leave air space around the heat sink or rear fan area. The microphone should have a clip or holder, and the cable should be routed where it can't snag the pedals or shifter.
Antenna and noise. A good antenna usually matters more than the choice between these radios. A roof-center NMO mount with a quality dual-band whip generally outperforms a trunk-lip or glass-mount setup, and SWR should be checked on both bands. Typical mobile noise sources include alternator whine, ignition and injector noise, LED lighting, USB chargers and DC-DC converters. On FM you may hear it as a need to raise the squelch or as whine in your transmitted audio. Routing the power cable away from the engine bay wiring harness, keeping it short and using ferrite chokes where they help are all common first steps. Isolate noise by unplugging or turning off accessories one at a time.
Etiquette. Listen before you transmit, especially if you use dual watch on a couple of repeaters. Keep transmissions short, give your callsign properly and don't treat the repeater as a private chat room while driving. Whatever your local law says about hands-free operation, keep your attention on the road. A voice command, a steering wheel PTT or just staying quiet in heavy traffic is better than fumbling with a touchscreen.
What have you found worth planning before the first drill hole goes in?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11254-dual-band-mobile-rigs-compared-ftm-500d-id-5100a-and-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-etiquette/Share on other sites