Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75, plus batteries, antennas, CHIRP and repeater offsets
- Replies 2
- Views 33
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing handheld radios and the practical details around them. The usual question is which HT to buy, but the answer depends on what you want it to do. A cheap analog dual-bander, a D-STAR handheld and a GPS/APRS-capable radio are different tools, and the accessories and programming matter almost as much as the radio.
Here is a rough sorting of the models people usually bring up. The Baofeng handhelds, such as the UV-5R family, are the low-cost entry point: analog FM, dual band 144/430 MHz, about 5 W or less. The Yaesu FT-65R is also an analog-only 2 m/70 cm radio, but it is a name-brand design with a simple interface and a reputation for solid receive performance for the price. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band handheld that adds D-STAR digital voice, GPS and Bluetooth alongside analog FM. The Kenwood TH-D75 adds D-STAR, a built-in GPS and APRS capability, and is tri-band in the US (144/220/430 MHz). Check the current spec sheets before buying, because regional versions and firmware differ.
One correction to a common mix-up: the Icom IC-705 is not really an HT. It is a portable HF/50/144/430 MHz transceiver with D-STAR that can run from a battery, so it fits portable and field-operation setups. It is bigger than a handheld and costs more, and it is built for a different job.
DMR deserves its own note, because none of the radios above are DMR handhelds. DMR means picking a radio from a different product line, getting a DMR ID, and loading a codeplug with the right color codes, time slots and talkgroups for the repeaters and networks you plan to use. D-STAR is a different system, with its own registration and callsign routing. Before choosing a digital mode, find out what your local repeaters actually run. A digital handheld is of little use if every active repeater near you is analog FM.
Some topics I'd like to see covered in the replies:
First, batteries. What is the best way to carry spares, and does an AA-cell case or a 12 V adapter belong in an emergency kit? Second, antennas. How much does the stock rubber duck limit you, and which upgrades are worth it? Third, programming. Where does CHIRP work well, and where do you need the manufacturer's software? Finally, repeater offsets and emergency use. How should a new operator prepare a radio so it is actually useful when someone else needs it?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11269-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-plus-batteries-antennas-chirp-and-repeater-offsets/Share on other sites