Where does your SDR noise floor actually come from? Dynamic range, upconverters and antennas for HF through VHF
- Replies 2
- Views 33
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
A lot of SDR buying and troubleshooting threads come down to one confusion: people treat sensitivity, dynamic range and antenna noise as the same thing. They are different limits, and which one you hit depends on the band. This thread is meant to lay out the pieces and compare approaches, so corrections are welcome.
ADC bits and what they buy you. The ideal SNR of an N-bit converter is roughly 6.02N + 1.76 dB. For 8 bits that is about 50 dB, for 12 bits about 74 dB, and for 14 bits about 86 dB. Real devices fall short of these figures because of ADC non-linearity, tuner noise and gain-stage compromises. That number applies across the whole sampled bandwidth. Narrowing the bandwidth with decimation and filtering gives processing gain, so a 2.4 MS/s capture analysed with a 500 Hz resolution bandwidth looks much quieter than the raw bit depth suggests. Weak signals are not what overloads an 8-bit dongle. The problem is a strong FM broadcast, medium-wave or pager signal inside the sampled window, which forces the gain down or produces intermodulation products that look like real signals.
The hardware families, roughly. The RTL-SDR (RTL2832U plus an R820T2-type tuner) is an 8-bit device that covers roughly 24 MHz to 1.7 GHz, with a stable bandwidth of about 2.4 MHz. It is excellent value for VHF/UHF work such as ADS-B, APRS, weather satellites and 433 MHz sensors. HackRF One covers 1 MHz to 6 GHz, is half-duplex, and is also 8-bit. Its strength is the huge frequency range and TX capability, not weak-signal HF reception. SDRplay RSP units and the Airspy range are the usual step up for receive. They use higher-resolution converters, cover down to the LF/HF range (the Airspy HF+ line is specifically tuned for HF and low VHF), and have built-in filtering. SDRplay also offers selectable notch filters and switchable bandpass filtering on some models. LimeSDR is a wideband transceiver with 12-bit converters and full duplex, and it suits experimenters more than casual listeners.
Upconverters versus direct sampling. Dongles whose tuners start around 24 MHz can reach HF in two ways. Direct sampling feeds the ADC without the tuner. It is simple and cheap, but it has no real preselection, so you need a low-pass filter before the input to limit aliasing and out-of-band signals. An upconverter mixes HF up by a fixed local-oscillator offset, commonly 100 or 125 MHz in popular designs, so that 0 to 30 MHz appears at 125 to 155 MHz. You then set a frequency offset or shift in the software so the display still reads the true frequency. Upconverters add a mixer and LO to the chain, so watch for LO leakage, spurs and images, and make sure a proper low-pass filter sits ahead of the mixer. Neither approach fixes the 8-bit limit.
Noise. On HF, especially below about 20 MHz, the limiting noise is usually external: man-made noise, switch-mode supplies, LED lighting, powerline noise and local computers. A very quiet receiver will not improve a noisy antenna site. A quick test is to connect the antenna and see whether the noise floor rises noticeably above what you see with a dummy load. If it rises clearly, you are external-noise-limited and more receiver sensitivity is unlikely to help. If it barely moves, the receiver front end is limiting, and a low-noise preamp or a better antenna may help. On VHF/UHF the situation is different, and feedline loss and the receiver's own noise figure matter more, so a masthead LNA can make a real difference.
Antennas. Small active E-field whips and loops can be useful where space is limited, but they can overload on strong signals and pick up noise from the feedline. A common-mode choke at the receiver end is a cheap first step against noise riding on the coax. A magnetic loop can reject some local electrical noise. A random wire with a 9:1 unun is broadband but picks up whatever is nearby. For VHF/UHF, a discone gives wide coverage for scanning, while a tuned dipole, V-dipole or ground plane usually performs better on one band, such as 137 MHz weather satellites or 1090 MHz ADS-B.
Software. SDR# is a popular Windows option with a plugin ecosystem. SDRuno is the SDRplay-focused Windows application with detailed multi-VFO and filtering controls. HDSDR is a Windows front end that uses ExtIO drivers and can be driven through OmniRig for CAT use. GQRX runs on Linux and macOS and is built on GNU Radio. CubicSDR is cross-platform and works through SoapySDR, which suits less common hardware. For digital modes, the usual approach is to route demodulated audio through a virtual audio cable into a decoder, for example WSJT-X for FT8, multimon-ng for POCSAG, or direwolf for APRS. The decoder cares about correct filter width, mode and a clean audio level, so check those before suspecting the decoder.
Questions for discussion: for people working on HF with a budget around an RTL-SDR, is direct sampling with a good filter or an upconverter the better first step? And for panadapter use, where do you tap the signal, and how do you protect the SDR front end during transmit?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11274-where-does-your-sdr-noise-floor-actually-come-from-dynamic-range-upconverters-and-antennas-for-hf-through-vhf/Share on other sites