Planning a remote HF station: IC-7610 vs Flex vs SCU-LAN10 vs RigPi, plus security, latency and licensing
- Replies 2
- Views 34
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'm sketching out a remote HF setup. The radio and antennas would sit at a quiet site with a decent tower, and I'd operate from a city apartment with a noisy RF environment. Before buying anything I want to compare the main approaches and work out where each one breaks down. This is a planning thread, not a report of something I've already built, so corrections are welcome.
The first split is between radios with network support built in and a generic server in front of any rig. The IC-7610 has an Ethernet port and works with Icom's RS-BA1 software, and the open-source wfview project can also talk to Icom LAN radios. FlexRadio is architecturally different. The radio is the server, SmartSDR runs on the client, and SmartLink handles the internet side. Yaesu's SCU-LAN10 is a network interface for supported radios, so check Yaesu's compatibility list for your exact model and firmware. RigPi and similar Raspberry Pi or PC based servers sit between any CAT-controllable rig and the network. They use something like Hamlib for control and a separate audio path, which makes them flexible but means more moving parts to maintain.
Then there is the other group of tools: WebSDR, KiwiSDR and RemoteHams.com. WebSDR and KiwiSDR are receive-only, shared SDR servers. They are useful as a second set of ears to check whether a band is open at a distant location, or whether the noise you hear is local or everywhere. They are not a way to transmit. RemoteHams.com is aimed at connecting remote station owners and users, so check the site for the current software, supported rigs and access rules before relying on any feature I describe here.
My open questions are these. How do you keep the station safe if the link drops while you are transmitting? What is the sane way to expose this to the internet? What latency can you tolerate for SSB, CW and FT8? And what do the licensing rules say when the station and the operator are in different places?
On safety, I think the radio should never be the only thing protecting itself. A remotely switchable power supply, a timeout timer, SWR and temperature monitoring, and a known antenna switch state all seem like the minimum. I would also want a way to reach the site's router and power control that does not depend on the radio software working.
On security, my instinct is to avoid port-forwarding a rig server directly and put a VPN in front of everything. That means WireGuard or a similar tunnel, a separate VLAN for the radio gear, unique passwords, and keeping firmware and the OS on any Pi up to date. Does that match what people consider sensible, or is it overkill for a hobby station?
On rules, I understand that remote control is generally permitted in many places, but the details differ. These include who counts as the control operator, which license privileges apply, whether the operator must be in the same country, and what a contest sponsor accepts. I will check the regulator's current text and the specific contest rules rather than assume. If anyone has pointers to where these questions are usually answered, I'd appreciate it.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11278-planning-a-remote-hf-station-ic-7610-vs-flex-vs-scu-lan10-vs-rigpi-plus-security-latency-and-licensing/Share on other sites