Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Ham Radio Base

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Ham Radio Base — Education, Resources, Projects and Community
☀ Solar
SFI 99
SN 26
A 6
K 0 Quiet
X-Ray B2.3
Wind 384.8 km/s
Aurora 1
Updated 13:30 UTC HamQSL · N0NBH
Day 80/40m Good 30/20m Good 17/15m Fair 12/10m Poor
Night 80/40m Good 30/20m Good 17/15m Fair 12/10m Poor

Callsign Lookup
_
Vanity Call Signs Available
Enter filters above and click Search.
ⓘ Callsign lookups are in real time via the FCC database. Vanity callsign availability is refreshed daily at 6:00 AM CST. The vanity search may be unavailable for a few minutes during this update.
Live DX spots
Live DX Spots — 70cm via PSKReporter · scroll or pinch to zoom
Band
Mode
Time
Loading map data…
MHz DX Spotter Info
Recent spots —
Select a band above to load spots
Ready — select a band to fetch live spots

Small lot or HOA: which compromise HF antenna first, and why SWR alone will mislead you

ci_cover.jpg

Here is a setup that comes up a lot. You have a lot of about 50 by 100 ft, one or two supports around 30 to 35 ft (a pole, a tree, or the roofline), and an HOA that dislikes anything that looks like a tower or a beam. The goal is general HF operating on 40 through 10 m, with some 80 m if it can be had. The question is which compromise antenna is worth building first, and what to measure besides SWR to know whether it works.

The usual candidates behave differently, so I'll lay out the tradeoffs.

An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) is a half-wave wire fed through a transformer of roughly 49:1 to 64:1, because the end of a half-wave wire is a high impedance of a few thousand ohms. It is quick to deploy, it is resonant on harmonically related bands (a 40 m version works on 40, 20, 15 and 10), and it needs only one high support. The weak points are that the transformer core can lose power or saturate, the feedline shield becomes part of the antenna, and bands that are not harmonically related need a tuner and will see losses. A common-mode choke on the coax a short distance from the transformer is usually sensible.

An off-center-fed dipole (OCFD) is fed about one third along the wire, usually through a 4:1 current balun. It gives multiband resonance on several bands with a more moderate feedpoint impedance than an EFHW, but its patterns and impedance vary by band, and it also benefits from a choke on the coax.

A G5RV is a 102 ft center-fed wire with a 34 ft ladder-line section into coax. It is really a doublet with a matching stub, and a tuner is needed on most bands. It needs a lot of horizontal span for its size, and the half-size version covers fewer bands. A plain doublet with ladder line to a tuner is the more flexible version of the same idea, as long as the tuner and a balun or choke at the radio handle the balanced line properly.

An inverted V needs one high support at the apex and the ends can be lower, which suits a small lot. Dropping the ends lowers the feedpoint impedance, often toward 50 ohms, and means the wire needs to be cut a bit shorter than a flat-top dipole. The pattern is more omnidirectional than a flat dipole and it tolerates a modest apex height better.

Verticals, trap dipoles, magnetic loops and Yagis each add their own issues. A vertical needs a good radial system or it dumps a lot of power into ground loss. A trap dipole gives multiband convenience at the cost of some bandwidth and efficiency from the trap losses. A magnetic loop is small enough for an attic or balcony, but it is narrow-band, must be retuned when you move a few kHz, and its efficiency drops quickly when the loop is small relative to the wavelength. A Yagi gives real gain but is hard to hide.

The part I most want to discuss is measurement. SWR shows how well the feedline load matches the transmitter, not how much power is radiated. A lossy antenna, such as a short vertical on poor radials or a loop with resistive joints, can show a good SWR because the loss resistance acts like a dummy load. Long runs of lossy coax can also make the SWR at the radio look better than it is at the antenna. A high SWR on low-loss ladder line can radiate nearly all your power, while a 1.1:1 reading may hide a lot of heat.

So the questions are these. Given one 35 ft support, would you start with an inverted-V doublet fed with ladder line, or an EFHW for simplicity? How much do you trust NEC modeling for something this compromised? And what practical comparison would you use besides SWR, such as signal reports, receive comparisons, or checking common-mode current on the coax?

  • Replies 2
  • Views 28
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Featured Replies

  • Moderators

With one 35 ft support and a tuner in the shack, I would lean toward a doublet as an inverted V, fed with ladder line or window line, and see how far that gets you. The reason is feedline loss. Balanced line has very low loss even at a high SWR, so the tuner can handle the mismatch on several bands without most of the power turning into heat. Coax feeding a compromise antenna on a band where the SWR is high wastes much more, particularly at 15 and 10 m, where coax loss per 100 ft is higher.

Some design details matter for this. The wire should be at least roughly a half-wave on the lowest band you want to work, so about 66 ft total for 40 m, and longer helps 80 m. Avoid lengths that give extreme feedpoint impedances on bands you care about, because the tuner has to deal with that, and the voltages on the ladder line can get large. Keep the ladder line away from metal gutters and downspouts, and bring it down with a few twists rather than hugging a wall.

At the radio end, a 4:1 current balun or a choke before the tuner keeps common-mode current off the coax, or use a tuner with a built-in balanced output. Without that, the shield can radiate, you get RF in the shack, and the pattern is distorted. On an HOA lot it also means more chance of interference with neighbors' equipment.

Wire thin enough to be inconspicuous, such as insulated 18 to 20 AWG stranded or coated wire, in a dark color against trees, is what makes most stealth wire antennas work in practice. It won't be the most efficient antenna, but it can work well on 40 through 10 m for the effort.

  • Moderators

I'd partly disagree: the doublet is more flexible, but the EFHW has a real advantage on a small lot, which is that it only needs a run of wire and one coax line. If you can't route ladder line cleanly and a tuner is awkward, an EFHW on 40 m with harmonic bands is easy to hide and cheap to try. The catch is that the transformer matters. A poorly built 49:1 or 64:1 can be lossy or run warm on higher power, and the match on the harmonics depends on the end-effect and nearby objects, so don't expect the SWR to be identical on every band.

A vertical may be the better pick if low-angle DX is the goal and the yard allows radials. The dilemma is that a ground-mounted quarter-wave needs many radials to avoid large ground loss. An elevated vertical with a small number of resonant radials per band can be a more efficient use of limited space. A vertical also has a noise issue: it often receives more local noise than a horizontal wire, so compare receive as well as transmit.

On testing, I'd combine several checks rather than one. An antenna analyzer shows resonance and feedpoint impedance, and putting a clamp-on current probe or a simple choke test on the coax shows common-mode problems. NEC modeling in 4nec2 or EZNEC is valuable for comparing designs, especially height and ground type, but ground parameters are approximate, so use it for relative comparisons, not exact gain. Then do on-air comparisons with the same station using both antennas in quick succession, such as WSPR, RBN, or PSKReporter spots, noting that propagation changes minute to minute.

For a magnetic loop, be realistic. It can be a very quiet receiver and is easy to hide, but the efficiency depends on the conductor diameter, the joints, and the capacitor, and a small loop on 40 m or lower gives a big efficiency penalty. If space is the only limit, a loop makes sense on 20 m and up, and I wouldn't expect it to match a decent wire on the lower bands.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Ham Radio Base earns from qualifying purchases. Some links throughout this website may be affiliate links. If you purchase a product through one of these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Your support helps us continue creating free articles, tutorials, reviews, and resources for the amateur radio community. N0TLB © Ham Radio Base - Powered by the Ham CQ DX Community. All rights reserved.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.