One go-kit for both POTA and SOTA: what to pack, what to leave behind, and where the compromises hurt
- Replies 2
- Views 28
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Starting a thread to compare notes on a single field kit that can handle a park activation from a picnic table and a summit climb with a longer carry. The two get lumped together, but they push the design in different directions. At a park you can bring a chair, a bigger battery and a long pole. On a summit every gram counts, the wind is stronger, and you may only have a short window before weather or daylight closes in.
Here is a baseline to argue with. A typical QRP-class kit is a 5 to 20 W radio, a 12 V LiFePO4 battery sized to the day, an end-fed half-wave (EFHW) or a linked dipole, a 7 to 10 m telescopic fiberglass pole, a coax run or a short feedline with a choke, a key or paddles, headphones, a logging method and a few small tools. Everything else is a judgment call.
A few points where people tend to disagree:
EFHW or linked dipole? An EFHW (a half-wave wire fed through a high-ratio transformer, commonly 49:1) is quick to deploy and works on a harmonically related set of bands, so a wire cut for 40 m also plays on 20, 15 and 10 m. It can be run as an inverted L or sloper off one support. The tradeoffs are that the transformer and any coax counterpoise or feedline can radiate, and the match gets less forgiving when the wire isn't cut properly or sits near the ground or trees. A linked dipole needs a center support and two legs, but the feedpoint is balanced, the match is usually flat on each band you built for, and you can add 30 m, 17 m or 12 m, which the harmonic series of a 40 m EFHW doesn't cover. The cost is stopping to move links at the wire ends, or at the center if you build it that way, every time you change bands.
Battery sizing. A small LiFePO4 pack is a good match for field use: it is lighter than sealed lead-acid, tolerates a deep discharge, and holds a flat voltage curve. Check your radio's maximum input voltage, though. A fully charged 4-cell LiFePO4 pack sits around 14.4 to 14.6 V, which some radios handle fine and others don't like. Check the spec sheet. Capacity is worth working out from the transmit duty cycle, not the rated power. A 10 W CW or SSB operator draws much less on average than the peak current suggests, and receive current matters over a long day.
Solar. A foldable panel can top up a pack between activations, but in practice it is more useful for camp or a long Field Day style setup than for a 90-minute summit stop. A charge controller that suits LiFePO4 chemistry matters more than the panel size.
Poles and guying. Telescopic fiberglass poles are convenient, but the lower sections can flex or slip when they get dirty or wet. Guying a pole with light cord, and using a bungee or stake at the base, makes a bigger difference to survival in wind than buying a longer pole. Keep the pole and wire clear of power lines and check the sky before raising anything tall.
Logging. Paper and pencil are still hard to beat when it is cold, wet or the battery is low. If you log to a phone or tablet, think about brightness and battery drain, and keep a paper backup. Log in UTC, and note the park or summit reference, band, mode and callsign for each contact. Check the current activation requirements for your program before you head out, because contact minimums and rules for spotting can change.
Questions for the thread: what is the first thing you would cut when the pack gets too heavy? Which single failure (pole, connector, battery, logging) is most likely to end an activation early? And how are you handling weather decisions when you are already at the top?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11302-one-go-kit-for-both-pota-and-sota-what-to-pack-what-to-leave-behind-and-where-the-compromises-hurt/Share on other sites