VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole vs collinear vs yagi, mobile mounts, coax and connectors, and what SWR does and doesn't tell you
- Replies 2
- Views 37
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Let's pull together the practical trade-offs for VHF/UHF antennas in one place. The same questions keep coming up: which antenna type for which job, how much gain is real, and why a good SWR reading doesn't always mean a good signal. Here is a framework to argue with.
Start with the job, not the antenna. A repeater user on 2 m/70 cm FM wants vertical polarization and a pattern that is round in azimuth. A weak-signal SSB/CW operator on 2 m, 70 cm or higher normally wants horizontal polarization and a directional beam. A LEO satellite operator needs something that copes with a moving target and changing polarization. Gain only helps if the pattern points where the signal is.
Quarter-wave and 5/8 wave whips. A quarter-wave is about 234/f(MHz) feet, minus a little for the velocity factor of the element. That is roughly 19 inches on 2 m and just over 6 inches on 70 cm. It needs a ground plane, such as a car roof, to act as the other half of the antenna. A 5/8 wave whip is taller, usually has a matching coil at the base, and puts more energy toward the horizon. The usual figure is a couple of dB over a quarter-wave. The real number depends on the ground plane and on how honest the manufacturer is, so treat catalog gain as best case. A 5/8 wave on a small or off-center ground plane can show a decent SWR and still radiate with a skewed pattern.
J-pole and Slim Jim. Both are end-fed half-wave antennas with a quarter-wave matching section. The J-pole is simple, cheap to build from copper pipe or twin-lead, and needs no radials in principle. In practice the coax shield can carry common-mode current and become part of the antenna, which distorts the pattern and moves the SWR depending on how the cable is routed. A choke of a few turns of coax or ferrite beads near the feedpoint often helps. The Slim Jim is a folded variant with a lower radiation angle, which can help on flat-terrain simplex or repeater work. As with any homebrew, accuracy of dimensions and a clean feedpoint matter more than the design name.
Collinears. Stacking phased half-wave sections flattens the elevation pattern. That concentrates energy toward the horizon, which is what you want for a base station or repeater in open terrain. The catch is that more gain means a narrower vertical beam. On a mast in hilly terrain, or when you're talking to stations well above or below you, a high-gain collinear can be worse than a modest antenna. Mounting also matters. A collinear beside a metal mast will have its pattern pulled off-center unless it is mounted with enough standoff or on top of the mast.
Yagis. A yagi trades coverage for gain and front-to-back ratio. Polarization needs to match: crossing vertical and horizontal polarization can cost on the order of 20 dB in practice, though reflections and ground effects vary it. Most FM repeater and simplex work uses vertical, and SSB/CW weak-signal work conventionally uses horizontal, so check local band-plan practice before committing to a mast orientation. For FM satellites, hand-held three-element yagis can work well because you can point them by hand and rotate them to find the best polarization. Crossed yagis with circular polarization (or switchable RHCP/LHCP) reduce fading from rotation of the satellite, at the cost of a more complex feed and phasing harness.
Mobile mounts. NMO needs a 3/4 inch hole but gives a solid, low-loss mechanical and electrical connection to the roof. It is the usual choice for permanent installs. A magnetic mount is quick to fit, but the coupling is partly capacitive through the paint, so the antenna can detune, and a dirty or scratched surface may degrade performance. Place the antenna at the center of the roof if you can. Running the coax through a door gasket can damage the cable or the weather seal, so a flat-profile cable or a route through a rubber grommet is neater.
Coax and connectors. PL-259 (UHF connectors) are common and fine for HF and often acceptable on 2 m. They are not constant-impedance and are not weatherproof, so loss and mismatch get worse by 440 MHz and above. N-type connectors are constant-impedance, weatherproof when properly sealed, and are the better choice for 70 cm and up. Cable loss climbs quickly with frequency. Approximate numbers: RG-58 loses roughly 5 to 6 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and 10 dB or more at 450 MHz, so keep it short. Low-loss types like LMR-400 or similar can be around 1.5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and under 3 dB at 450 MHz. Check the datasheet for your exact cable.
SWR. SWR measures how well the antenna and feedline match the transmitter's impedance. It isn't a measure of efficiency or gain. A dummy load has a perfect SWR and radiates nothing. Lossy coax can also make the SWR look better at the radio than it really is at the antenna, because power lost in the cable on its way to and from the mismatch reduces the reflection that you see. For a fair test, measure at the antenna end if possible, away from metal clutter, with the antenna in the position it will be used in.
Repeater and satellite antennas. A repeater system with a shared antenna needs a duplexer to keep transmit energy out of the receiver. If separate antennas are used, vertical separation is more effective than horizontal separation for isolation. For satellite work, the key practical points are pointing accuracy, polarization, and Doppler shift, which will move the received frequency noticeably on 70 cm during a pass.
So what's your use case, and which of these compromises do you find hardest to make? Share the band, the terrain, and whether you're on a rooftop, mast, or vehicle, and we can narrow things down.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11305-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-collinear-vs-yagi-mobile-mounts-coax-and-connectors-and-what-swr-does-and-doesnt-tell-you/Share on other sites