Building CW speed the sensible way: Farnsworth, keyers, filters and when to trust a decoder
- Replies 2
- Views 33
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This is a general discussion thread for anyone working on CW operating skill, whether you're still learning characters or trying to get comfortable in a contest pileup. The same few questions come up repeatedly, so here are the main points and some open questions for the group.
Learning and Farnsworth timing. Farnsworth sends each character at a faster speed (say 18-20 WPM) but stretches the gaps between characters and words, so the overall rate is slower. The point is that you learn each letter as a rhythmic sound ("dah-di-dit") rather than counting dits and dahs. If you learn at a true 5 WPM, you tend to hit a wall later when you have to unlearn the counting habit. Many people use Farnsworth or the Koch method (starting with two characters at full speed and adding more as you reach about 90% accuracy). The open question is when to reduce the extra spacing. A common answer is to shrink the gaps gradually until the character speed and overall speed match.
Keys and paddles. A straight key is simple and gives you full control over timing, but fast sending gets tiring. Iambic paddles with an electronic keyer make the dits and dahs for you, and squeezing both paddles alternates them. Mode A and Mode B differ in what happens when you release the squeeze: Mode B adds one extra opposite element, which some operators like and others find annoying. A bug (a semi-automatic key such as those made by Vibroplex) makes automatic dits with a pendulum and leaves dashes manual, which gives it a distinctive "fist." Boutique paddle makers such as N3ZN get mentioned a lot for smooth feel and adjustability. The thing that matters most is that the paddle's travel, tension and contact spacing suit your hand. A good paddle set too heavy or too light can feel worse than a cheap one adjusted well.
Sending quality. Clean spacing matters more than raw speed. Evenly sent characters at 22 WPM are easier to copy than ragged ones at 30. Check your weighting and your inter-character spacing, and if your rig has a keyer memory, record yourself and listen back.
Receiving, filters and QSK. A narrow CW filter (often somewhere between 200 and 500 Hz, depending on conditions and the receiver) can cut adjacent signals dramatically, but very narrow settings can cause ringing that smears the characters. Matching your sidetone and receive pitch to a comfortable note (many people like 500-700 Hz) helps you tune to the right frequency. QSK, or full break-in, lets you hear between your own elements, so the other station can interrupt you. It's very useful in a contest or on a busy net, though it depends on how fast your transceiver switches between transmit and receive, and relay noise can be distracting. Semi break-in with a short hang time is a fine alternative.
Abbreviations and prosigns. The usual things: CQ, DE, K, KN, AR (end of message), SK (end of contact), BT (pause or separator), UR, RST, TU, 73. In contests, cut numbers are used, such as 5NN for 599. Prosigns are sent as a single character with no gap between the letters, so AR is sent as .-.-. rather than A-R. Q-signals, such as QRS (send more slowly), QRQ (send faster), QRL? (is the frequency in use?) and QSB (fading), are also part of everyday CW.
Skimmers and decoders. CW Skimmer can decode many signals across a band segment simultaneously, which is useful for spotting and for feeding the Reverse Beacon Network. Single-signal decoders work well on clean, steady, machine-sent code and poorly on weak, fading or hand-sent signals with irregular timing. The question for the thread: do you think leaning on a decoder slows down learning to copy by ear, or is it a harmless confidence check?
Contests. A CW contest is a good way to build speed, because the exchanges are short and repetitive. Often the best way in is to run low power on a few bands, or to answer CQs from stations calling at a speed you can manage, and gradually move up to calling CQ yourself.
What has been the most useful change for you in building speed or accuracy: the key or paddle, the filter setup, a training method, or something else?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11318-building-cw-speed-the-sensible-way-farnsworth-keyers-filters-and-when-to-trust-a-decoder/Share on other sites