Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Ham Radio Base

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Ham Radio Base — Education, Resources, Projects and Community
☀ Solar
SFI 99
SN 26
A 6
K 0 Quiet
X-Ray B2.3
Wind 384.8 km/s
Aurora 1
Updated 13:30 UTC HamQSL · N0NBH
Day 80/40m Good 30/20m Good 17/15m Fair 12/10m Poor
Night 80/40m Good 30/20m Good 17/15m Fair 12/10m Poor

Callsign Lookup
_
Vanity Call Signs Available
Enter filters above and click Search.
ⓘ Callsign lookups are in real time via the FCC database. Vanity callsign availability is refreshed daily at 6:00 AM CST. The vanity search may be unavailable for a few minutes during this update.
Live DX spots
Live DX Spots — 70cm via PSKReporter · scroll or pinch to zoom
Band
Mode
Time
Loading map data…
MHz DX Spotter Info
Recent spots —
Select a band above to load spots
Ready — select a band to fetch live spots

Small lot, one HF antenna: EFHW, OCFD, doublet or vertical? What actually decides it

ci_cover.jpg

This question comes up constantly, and the answers usually turn into a brand war. So here is a concrete scenario to argue about. Take a suburban lot with one support around 30 to 35 ft (a mast or a tree), a second support about 60 ft away at roughly 15 to 20 ft, and a shack with a 75 to 100 ft run to the base of the main support. There is an HOA, so nothing that looks like an antenna. The goal is 40 through 10 m, mostly SSB and FT8, with a sensible 80 m option if one exists.

The candidates that usually get named:

An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer. It is easy to hang, covers 40/20/15/10 on harmonics, and needs no tuner on those bands. The catch is that the feedpoint is a few thousand ohms and there is no real counterpoise. The coax shield becomes part of the antenna unless you choke it properly.

An off-center fed dipole (OCFD) with a 4:1 current balun, fed about a third of the way along. It covers 80/40/20/15/10 on paper, but the feedpoint impedance on each band depends on where the feed sits relative to the standing-wave pattern, and the radiation patterns change on the harmonics.

A doublet fed with open-wire or ladder line into a balanced or 4:1-balun tuner. This is the most flexible option, since a 130 ft flat top works on 80 m and everything above it. The cost is the feedline routing and a tuner that can handle high-reactance loads.

A vertical, either a ground-mounted one with radials or a stealthy flagpole-style one. It gives a low takeoff angle for DX, but a vertical is only as good as its ground system.

My view is that matching and SWR are the least interesting part of the comparison. The things that decide performance are (1) height of the radiating part in wavelengths, (2) whether common-mode current is controlled, (3) loss in the feedline and matching network, and (4) whether the pattern suits the contacts you want. A 1.1:1 SWR into a lossy system is a dummy load with extra steps.

For example, a 40 m dipole at 20 ft is only about 0.14 wavelength high. It is a good regional or NVIS-style antenna and mediocre for DX because most of the energy goes up at high angles. The same wire at 20 ft on 15 m is about 0.3 wavelength high, which is much more useful. So the height you have changes which bands are "DX bands" for that antenna.

Questions for the thread. If you had to choose one antenna for that lot, which and why? Is the doublet's feedline hassle worth it compared with an EFHW? And for stealth, does a vertical with four to eight elevated radials beat a low sloper or inverted V in practice, or does the answer depend entirely on the band?

  • Replies 2
  • Views 33
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Featured Replies

  • Moderators

I would split the problem into "where does the RF go" and "how do I get power into the antenna." Most arguments about EFHW versus doublet mix the two up.

With an EFHW, the 49:1 transformer sits at a high-impedance point, but any current that does not return on the wire has to return somewhere. If there is no counterpoise, it goes onto the outside of the coax. That is why a good EFHW setup usually has a common-mode choke right at the transformer output, or a deliberate counterpoise of a few feet to a quarter wave. Without that, the SWR may look excellent, but the shack gets RF, the pattern is distorted, and the feedline is half the antenna. With the choke and some counterpoise, it works well, especially if it is hung as a sloper or inverted V with the high-voltage end well clear of people and metal.

The doublet has the opposite property. It is balanced, so the feedline radiates little if the line stays symmetric and the tuner or balun is decent. Window line or ladder line has very low loss at HF. The loss that matters is in the tuner and in any coax between the tuner and the radio, especially when the load is far from 50 ohms. A short coax run to a choke balun on the tuner output is fine. A doublet on a band where the line sees very high SWR can turn a decent tuner into a space heater, so pick the flat-top length and line length with that in mind. A random line length is not always your friend.

Also think about coax loss. RG-58-type cable at 14 MHz is roughly 1 dB per 100 ft when matched, and a bit worse at 28 MHz. Mismatch adds loss on top of that. If the shack is 75 to 100 ft from the antenna, use better coax or move the matching point closer to the antenna. This also favors ladder line in the doublet case.

If the lot is small, I would go with the doublet for flexibility and put the EFHW second as the quick-deploy option. I would not call the OCFD either better or worse, but its behavior on the harmonics is less predictable than people assume, so model it for your height before building.

  • Administrators

On the vertical question, the honest answer is "it depends on the radials." A quarter-wave vertical over a poor ground system can lose a large share of its power as heat in the soil. That loss shows up as a nice, low SWR because the ground resistance is added to the feedpoint resistance, so the SWR actually improves when the antenna gets less efficient.

There are two ways to deal with that. One is many ground-level radials, on the order of dozens if you want the loss low, buried or laid on the surface. The other is an elevated system, where a few resonant radials a few feet above ground (four is common, more is better) can do well because the fields are not heavily coupled into lossy soil. Elevated radials need to be cut for each band, which means a multiband vertical gets complicated fast. That is why people use a trap vertical or a vertical with a tuner and a loaded radial set, and accept some compromises.

For HOA use, the vertical has a good property: it can be thin, and if it is a pole or a flagpole it is often visually accepted. If you can fit a short vertical dipole or a vertical with a feed-line choke, it will also be easy to move. Its downside is that it is vertically polarized and tends to pick up local noise more than a horizontal wire, especially in a suburban setting with a lot of switching power supplies.

An inverted V is a very good compromise on a lot like this. Put the apex as high as you can, with an included angle of about 90 to 120 degrees. The resonant frequency will drop compared with a flat dipole, so cut it a little long and trim. The impedance near the feedpoint tends to be close to 50 ohms for a wide angle, so a 1:1 current choke and coax are enough on its design band. Remember that the ends are low and carry high voltage, so keep them out of reach.

Finally, a magnetic loop belongs in this thread as a last-resort option. Small loops are narrow-band and need retuning when you move more than a few kHz, and their efficiency depends heavily on the quality of the conductor, the capacitor and every joint. On 40 m and below, a small loop can be very inefficient, though it can be quiet on receive and fit where nothing else will. For 20 m and up it becomes much more attractive. If you can hang a wire, the wire will usually beat the loop on 40 m and 80 m.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Ham Radio Base earns from qualifying purchases. Some links throughout this website may be affiliate links. If you purchase a product through one of these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Your support helps us continue creating free articles, tutorials, reviews, and resources for the amateur radio community. N0TLB © Ham Radio Base - Powered by the Ham CQ DX Community. All rights reserved.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.