ⓘ Callsign lookups are in real time via the FCC database.
Vanity callsign availability is refreshed daily at 6:00 AM CST.
The vanity search may be unavailable for a few minutes during this update.
Live DX spots
Live DX Spots — 70cmvia PSKReporter · scroll or pinch to zoom
Band
Mode
Time
Loading map data…
MHzDXSpotterInfo
Recent spots—
Select a band above to load spots
Ready — select a band to fetch live spots
Small lot, one HF antenna: EFHW, OCFD, doublet or vertical? What actually decides it
This question comes up constantly, and the answers usually turn into a brand war. So here is a concrete scenario to argue about. Take a suburban lot with one support around 30 to 35 ft (a mast or a tree), a second support about 60 ft away at roughly 15 to 20 ft, and a shack with a 75 to 100 ft run to the base of the main support. There is an HOA, so nothing that looks like an antenna. The goal is 40 through 10 m, mostly SSB and FT8, with a sensible 80 m option if one exists.
The candidates that usually get named:
An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer. It is easy to hang, covers 40/20/15/10 on harmonics, and needs no tuner on those bands. The catch is that the feedpoint is a few thousand ohms and there is no real counterpoise. The coax shield becomes part of the antenna unless you choke it properly.
An off-center fed dipole (OCFD) with a 4:1 current balun, fed about a third of the way along. It covers 80/40/20/15/10 on paper, but the feedpoint impedance on each band depends on where the feed sits relative to the standing-wave pattern, and the radiation patterns change on the harmonics.
A doublet fed with open-wire or ladder line into a balanced or 4:1-balun tuner. This is the most flexible option, since a 130 ft flat top works on 80 m and everything above it. The cost is the feedline routing and a tuner that can handle high-reactance loads.
A vertical, either a ground-mounted one with radials or a stealthy flagpole-style one. It gives a low takeoff angle for DX, but a vertical is only as good as its ground system.
My view is that matching and SWR are the least interesting part of the comparison. The things that decide performance are (1) height of the radiating part in wavelengths, (2) whether common-mode current is controlled, (3) loss in the feedline and matching network, and (4) whether the pattern suits the contacts you want. A 1.1:1 SWR into a lossy system is a dummy load with extra steps.
For example, a 40 m dipole at 20 ft is only about 0.14 wavelength high. It is a good regional or NVIS-style antenna and mediocre for DX because most of the energy goes up at high angles. The same wire at 20 ft on 15 m is about 0.3 wavelength high, which is much more useful. So the height you have changes which bands are "DX bands" for that antenna.
Questions for the thread. If you had to choose one antenna for that lot, which and why? Is the doublet's feedline hassle worth it compared with an EFHW? And for stealth, does a vertical with four to eight elevated radials beat a low sloper or inverted V in practice, or does the answer depend entirely on the band?
This question comes up constantly, and the answers usually turn into a brand war. So here is a concrete scenario to argue about. Take a suburban lot with one support around 30 to 35 ft (a mast or a tree), a second support about 60 ft away at roughly 15 to 20 ft, and a shack with a 75 to 100 ft run to the base of the main support. There is an HOA, so nothing that looks like an antenna. The goal is 40 through 10 m, mostly SSB and FT8, with a sensible 80 m option if one exists.
The candidates that usually get named:
An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer. It is easy to hang, covers 40/20/15/10 on harmonics, and needs no tuner on those bands. The catch is that the feedpoint is a few thousand ohms and there is no real counterpoise. The coax shield becomes part of the antenna unless you choke it properly.
An off-center fed dipole (OCFD) with a 4:1 current balun, fed about a third of the way along. It covers 80/40/20/15/10 on paper, but the feedpoint impedance on each band depends on where the feed sits relative to the standing-wave pattern, and the radiation patterns change on the harmonics.
A doublet fed with open-wire or ladder line into a balanced or 4:1-balun tuner. This is the most flexible option, since a 130 ft flat top works on 80 m and everything above it. The cost is the feedline routing and a tuner that can handle high-reactance loads.
A vertical, either a ground-mounted one with radials or a stealthy flagpole-style one. It gives a low takeoff angle for DX, but a vertical is only as good as its ground system.
My view is that matching and SWR are the least interesting part of the comparison. The things that decide performance are (1) height of the radiating part in wavelengths, (2) whether common-mode current is controlled, (3) loss in the feedline and matching network, and (4) whether the pattern suits the contacts you want. A 1.1:1 SWR into a lossy system is a dummy load with extra steps.
For example, a 40 m dipole at 20 ft is only about 0.14 wavelength high. It is a good regional or NVIS-style antenna and mediocre for DX because most of the energy goes up at high angles. The same wire at 20 ft on 15 m is about 0.3 wavelength high, which is much more useful. So the height you have changes which bands are "DX bands" for that antenna.
Questions for the thread. If you had to choose one antenna for that lot, which and why? Is the doublet's feedline hassle worth it compared with an EFHW? And for stealth, does a vertical with four to eight elevated radials beat a low sloper or inverted V in practice, or does the answer depend entirely on the band?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11328-small-lot-one-hf-antenna-efhw-ocfd-doublet-or-vertical-what-actually-decides-it/Share on other sites