Choosing a first (or next) handheld: FT-65R vs Baofeng vs ID-52A vs TH-D75, and where the IC-705 fits
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This question comes up constantly: which handheld should you buy, and how much radio do you need? I'd like this thread to collect practical thinking rather than a spec-sheet fight. Here is the landscape as I understand it, and please correct me where I'm off.
The budget analog tier. The Yaesu FT-65R is a 144/430 MHz dual band FM handheld at the 5 W class. It has no GPS, Bluetooth, or digital modes. People tend to pick it over the cheapest Baofeng models for its more conventional receiver behavior and its fit and finish. The Baofeng UV-5R family is cheaper and very widely used, and it works for basic repeater and simplex contact. The usual complaints are a front end that overloads easily near strong transmitters, spurious emissions on some models, and stock antennas that perform poorly. If you live near a high-power paging or broadcast site, receiver quality matters more than the feature list.
The digital-voice tier. The Icom ID-52A is a dual band D-STAR handheld that also does analog FM. The Kenwood TH-D75 adds 220 MHz in the North American version, and also does D-STAR, APRS, GPS, and Bluetooth. Both cost far more than an FT-65R. What you are buying is D-STAR access and the integrated data features, not extra range. If nobody near you runs D-STAR repeaters or reflectors, that money buys features you won't use. Check your local repeater directory before deciding.
DMR. This is a separate path. DMR handhelds are often cheaper than the D-STAR ones, but the setup is more involved: a radio ID, color codes, time slots, talkgroups, and a codeplug. Programming goes through the manufacturer's software or a third-party tool, not just CHIRP. It rewards people who like tinkering, and it can frustrate people who just want to push the button.
The IC-705. It gets listed with handhelds, but it is really a compact portable transceiver covering HF, 50, 144, and 430 MHz with D-STAR support. It is for portable HF/SOTA/POTA-style operation, not a replacement for something on your belt. Compare it to an HF rig, not to an HT.
Antennas and batteries. Replacing the stock antenna is probably the cheapest performance upgrade for any of these. A longer 144/430 whip, or a roll-up J-pole for stationary use, often beats the stock rubber duck. Check the connector first: many handhelds use an SMA-female jack on the radio, but some differ, and adapters add loss. For batteries, buy a spare pack from the manufacturer or a reputable source, and keep one charged. Handhelds drain quickly on high power with long transmissions. Where available, an AA-cell case is a useful fallback.
Programming and offsets. CHIRP supports many analog models, including the FT-65R and many Baofeng radios. Check its supported-radio list for the specific model you buy, since digital radios have limited or no support. Always download the radio's current image and save a backup before you write anything. On repeaters, the offset is not universal. Many US 2 m repeaters use ±600 kHz and many 70 cm repeaters use ±5 MHz, but the sign and the CTCSS tone depend on the repeater and the band plan. In other regions the 70 cm offset is different, so use a local repeater directory rather than assuming.
Emergency use. A handheld alone has limited range. Program your local repeaters, the simplex calling frequencies in your region, and any local net frequencies before you need them. Practice with the radio's menu so you aren't learning it under stress. Also remember that licensing matters: amateur bands need an amateur license, and some inexpensive radios can transmit on frequencies where you are not authorized.
So, what's your priority: lowest cost, best receiver, digital modes, or portability? What does your local repeater scene use?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11382-choosing-a-first-or-next-handheld-ft-65r-vs-baofeng-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-fits/Share on other sites