Dual-band mobile setup: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and cross-band repeat
- Replies 2
- Views 31
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'm putting together a checklist for a 2 m / 70 cm mobile install and want to compare notes. The three radios that come up most for a 50 W dual-band mobile are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. They overlap on the basics (2 m and 70 cm, roughly 50 W on VHF, detachable control head) but differ in what they're built around.
The FTM-500D is a Yaesu System Fusion (C4FM) radio that also does analog FM. The ID-5100A is Icom's D-STAR mobile with a touchscreen, and the TM-D710G is an analog FM radio with a built-in APRS TNC and GPS support. If you don't care about any digital mode, the decision gets much simpler. Pick the one whose menus you can live with and whose control head fits the space you have.
Here are the install topics I'd like to cover, starting with power, since that's where I see the most shortcuts.
Power and fusing. A 50 W FM mobile can pull roughly 10 to 12 A on transmit at full power. Check the spec sheet for your radio rather than trusting my number. The usual approach is a dedicated run straight to the battery, not the cigarette lighter socket and not a random accessory circuit. The fuse belongs in the positive lead close to the battery terminal, because its job is to protect the wire. A fuse near the radio doesn't protect the length of cable behind it. Use the fuse rating the manual calls for, and size the wire for the current and the round-trip length. Thin wire adds voltage drop, and the radio can behave badly on transmit peaks. Route the cable away from sharp edges, and use a grommet where it passes through the firewall.
Mounting. The main unit needs airflow around the heatsink or fan, and it shouldn't sit where a knee or a seatbelt buckle will hit it. The control head should be where you can reach it without taking your eyes off the road for long. Whatever you choose, make sure nothing is in the airbag deployment zone.
Antenna and coax. A roof-center NMO mount on a 2 m / 70 cm antenna is the cleanest setup, but trunk-lip and magnetic mounts work if you take SWR readings and keep the ground contact solid. Coax loss matters more on 70 cm than on 2 m, so avoid long runs of thin coax for UHF.
Noise. Alternator whine, ignition hash and switching noise from cheap USB chargers, dash cams and LED lighting are the usual suspects. Isolate the source by turning accessories off one at a time and listening on a quiet frequency. Ferrite cores on power leads can help, but fixing the source or relocating the wiring usually works better than adding filters.
Cross-band repeat. Some mobiles can retransmit what they hear on one band onto the other, so a handheld can work through the mobile's higher-power signal and better antenna. Whether and how each of these three radios supports it, and what the menu setup looks like, is something to confirm in the current manual for your exact model and firmware. On the regulatory side, you're still the control operator, so station identification and band-plan rules still apply, and you should choose frequencies that won't land on a repeater input or someone's net.
Etiquette. Keep transmissions short, identify properly, listen before keying up, and don't tie up a busy repeater with a long conversation. Drive first and talk second. Know your local rules on handheld device use in vehicles, and consider a speaker mic or a Bluetooth option if your radio supports it.
What have I missed? In particular I'd like to hear how people handle grounding and where they run the power lead on vehicles with start-stop systems or smart alternators.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11410-dual-band-mobile-setup-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-cross-band-repeat/Share on other sites