Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs. Baofeng vs. D-STAR/DMR HTs, plus batteries, antennas, CHIRP and emergency setup
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
Handheld questions tend to blur together: which radio to buy, why the repeater won't open, whether a $30 radio is good enough. I'd like to split it into a few separate decisions and get opinions on each.
1. Analog FM dual-bander or digital? A plain 2 m/70 cm FM handheld such as the Yaesu FT-65R or a Baofeng UV-5R-class radio covers most of what a new licensee needs: local repeaters, simplex, and nets. The FT-65R is a 5 W dual-bander with no GPS or digital modes, and it is generally regarded as a step up from the cheapest imports in receiver behavior and build. Digital adds capability, but also complexity. The ID-52A and TH-D75 are D-STAR handhelds, and both add GPS and Bluetooth. The TH-D75 also has APRS built in and, in the US version, a 220 MHz band. Neither does DMR. For DMR you are looking at other manufacturers, and the radio is only half of it: you also need a DMR ID, a codeplug, and an understanding of color codes, time slots and talkgroups.
2. Where does the IC-705 fit? It gets lumped in with HTs, but it is a portable HF/VHF/UHF transceiver, not a handie-talkie. It also supports D-STAR. It makes sense if you want HF for portable operation and also want VHF/UHF. If your main need is a radio on your belt or in a go-bag for local comms, a true HT is the better fit.
3. Batteries. Most HTs ship with a Li-ion pack, and a spare pack is often the cheapest way to extend runtime. Many models also have an AA battery case for a backup that works with store-bought cells. Keep in mind that high power draws more current, and transmitting uses far more than receiving. A radio that sits on standby all day can still be flat by evening. Check the charging method too: a drop-in cradle is convenient, but a USB-powered charger is easier to run from a power bank.
4. Antennas. The stock rubber duck is a compromise. A longer, better-tuned whip often improves both transmit and receive on a handheld, and a roll-up J-pole or similar antenna on a pole can help more than any radio upgrade. Check the connector first, because SMA male and female are easy to mix up between brands. Check SWR if you can, and avoid transmitting into a damaged or mismatched antenna.
5. Programming with CHIRP. CHIRP is free and supports many radios, but check your exact model on its supported list. Download the current configuration from the radio and save that image as a backup before you edit anything. Cable problems are very common, and counterfeit USB-serial chips and driver issues are often the real culprit when the radio won't talk to the PC. Programming by hand is fine for a few memories, but CHIRP saves time once you have a lot of channels.
6. Repeater offsets. In the US, the usual offsets are 600 kHz on 2 m (plus above 147.000 MHz, minus below that, with exceptions) and 5 MHz on 70 cm (plus above 447.000 MHz, minus below that). Other regions differ, so check your local bandplan, and don't rely on the radio's automatic offset without confirming it against the repeater listing. Also confirm the CTCSS tone: you may need to encode a tone to open the repeater, and some repeaters need tone squelch or a different tone on receive.
7. Emergency use. A handheld is a tool for the first minutes and for short-range coordination, not a replacement for a plan. Program known repeaters, simplex channels and any local net frequencies before you need them, and keep a printed copy. Make sure you are licensed for the services you transmit on, and practice with your group, since the radio's menu is a poor place to learn under stress.
What would you pick first for a new licensee, and what would you change as needs grow?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11412-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-baofeng-vs-d-stardmr-hts-plus-batteries-antennas-chirp-and-emergency-setup/Share on other sites