How do you combine SFI, K index, WSPR and beacons to decide which band to try?
- Replies 2
- Views 34
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Mike 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
There are many propagation numbers and tools, and they answer different questions. I'd like to compare approaches for turning them into a decision about where to point the antenna. This is the rough framework I use for thinking about it, so please correct it where it's wrong.
Long-term and seasonal: sunspot cycle, SFI, VOACAP. The 10.7 cm solar flux (SFI) is a convenient proxy for the solar ultraviolet that ionizes the F layer. Higher SFI generally means a higher MUF, so the upper bands (15, 12, 10 m) open more often and for longer. As a rule of thumb, an SFI near 70 is solar-minimum territory where 10 m is mostly dead except for sporadic E, and values well above 100 start to make the higher bands more reliable. VOACAP-based predictors use a smoothed sunspot number and give a monthly median, so they tell you what is likely at a given hour and season, not what is happening today. They're good for planning, such as which hours to try 17 m to a given region. They're not a live band report.
Day-to-day: A index and K index. The K index is a 3-hour measure of geomagnetic disturbance on a 0 to 9 scale, and the A index is a daily figure derived from it. Quiet conditions (low K) are usually better for HF, especially on high-latitude and polar paths. Disturbed conditions can depress F2 MUF, add auroral flutter and cause absorption on paths near the poles. Solar flares are a separate problem. They can cause a sudden increase in D-layer absorption on the sunlit side of the Earth, which blacks out HF for a while, mostly on the lower frequencies.
Layers and time of day. The D layer exists mainly in daylight and absorbs lower frequencies, which is why 160 and 80 m are mostly local during the day, and 40 m is limited to shorter distances. After sunset the D layer fades and the F layer carries the signal. The gray line, the day/night terminator, can give enhanced paths because you have low absorption at the sunset or sunrise end while the F layer is still working. Paths along the terminator are worth checking on the low bands.
Shorter-range and VHF modes. Sporadic E is not tied closely to SFI. It's patchy, short-lived clouds of ionization, mostly in late spring and early summer in the northern hemisphere, with a smaller peak around midwinter. It can open 10 m and 6 m for single-hop distances of roughly 1000 to 2300 km, and occasionally 2 m. Tropospheric ducting is a different thing. It's associated with temperature inversions and stable high pressure, often over water, and affects VHF/UHF and up. NVIS is for regional coverage of up to a few hundred kilometres. You pick a frequency below the critical frequency (foF2) so the signal goes nearly straight up and comes down on the area around you. It's often 80 or 60 m at night and 40 m during the day, but at low solar activity foF2 can drop enough that 40 m skips over you at night.
Real-time checking: WSPR and beacons. Predictions and indices tell you what should happen. Spots tell you what is happening. WSPR uses very low power and weak-signal decoding, so a 1 W or 5 W transmission can show which bands and paths are open, with reports on wsprnet.org. The NCDXF/IARU beacon network on 14.100, 18.110, 21.150, 24.930 and 28.200 MHz runs a repeating 3-minute cycle, so you can listen for a few minutes and see which regions are audible on each band. For CW, RTTY and digital modes, the Reverse Beacon Network and PSKReporter show who is hearing whom in near real time.
My question is about workflow. What do you check first before you sit down to operate: indices, a prediction program, or live spots? And how do you handle cases where the numbers look bad but the spots say the band is open (or the other way round)?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11432-how-do-you-combine-sfi-k-index-wspr-and-beacons-to-decide-which-band-to-try/Share on other sites