Choosing an HT: FT-65R vs Baofeng vs D-STAR/DMR handhelds, plus batteries, antennas, CHIRP and emergency use
- Replies 2
- Views 25
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Mike 1 post
I'd like to sort out how people choose a handheld, because the usual advice mixes together very different tools. The radios I keep seeing compared are the Baofeng UV-5R family, the Yaesu FT-65R, the Icom ID-52A, the Kenwood TH-D75, and sometimes the Icom IC-705, even though the IC-705 isn't really an HT. Here's how I'd group them, and I'd like corrections.
Budget analog dual-banders (Baofeng UV-5R style, Yaesu FT-65R). Both cover 2 m and 70 cm FM at roughly 5 W. That is plenty for local repeaters and simplex. The FT-65R is generally regarded as having a cleaner transmitter, better build quality and a more predictable menu than the cheapest clones. The Baofeng's main advantages are price and the huge supply of accessories and programming cables. If your goal is repeaters, simplex and a backup radio, either is a reasonable start. Just be aware that the cheap clones are often criticized for weak receiver selectivity (strong nearby pagers or public-safety transmitters can desense them) and for spurious or harmonic output.
Digital voice handhelds (ID-52A, TH-D75, DMR radios). The ID-52A is a D-STAR dual-band handheld, and the TH-D75 adds 220 MHz and builds in APRS and GPS features. These radios only make sense if your area has active D-STAR repeaters or hotspots. The same goes for DMR: before you buy, check whether local repeaters exist, which networks they link to, and which talkgroups people use. DMR also requires a registered DMR ID and a codeplug with channels, color codes, timeslots and talkgroups. That is a bigger learning curve than analog FM.
IC-705. It's a portable all-mode transceiver covering HF, 6 m, 2 m and 70 cm, with D-STAR. It is great for portable operation, but it's a small radio that needs an external antenna, not a handheld you carry on your belt. The internal battery also gives lower power than the radio's maximum, so check the specs for your use case.
Programming. CHIRP is free, open source and supports a wide range of analog radios, including many Baofeng models. Download the radio's current image first and save it as a backup. Then edit and upload your channel list. You can import repeaters from lists such as RepeaterBook. Programming cables are a common problem. A loose connector or a bad USB-serial chip can fail without an obvious error, so seat the plug fully. CHIRP is mostly for analog work. DMR radios typically use their manufacturer's CPS or other dedicated software.
Repeater offsets. These are a frequent source of confusion. In the US, 2 m repeaters usually use a 600 kHz offset and 70 cm repeaters use 5 MHz. The direction depends on the sub-band and local coordination. Other countries differ, so check your local band plan. Also confirm whether the repeater needs a CTCSS tone on transmit. A common mistake is setting tone squelch when you only need tone encode. The Reverse key, which lets you listen on the repeater's input frequency, helps you tell whether you are in simplex range of the other station.
Batteries and antennas. A spare battery is probably the most useful accessory. Some radios take an optional AA tray, which is handy if power is out and you can't recharge. Using low power for local repeaters extends battery life. The stock rubber duck is a compromise. A longer, well-made whip or a better-designed telescoping antenna can noticeably improve results, as can holding the radio higher and away from your body. Check the connector type before buying, because SMA male/female and reverse variants differ by radio. Don't transmit without an antenna attached.
Emergency use. Always write down your local repeater frequencies, offsets and tones on paper, along with a few simplex channels. Repeaters can lose power or links, and your phone-based list may also fail. Practice with your local net before an event, and learn how your local emergency group organizes communications. Keep everything legal: operate only on frequencies your license allows, and do not use a radio just because it is capable of transmitting on public-safety or GMRS frequencies.
So the question: if you could buy only one HT today, would you go with a cheap analog radio and invest in a good antenna and spare batteries, or step up to a D-STAR/DMR model only if your area supports it?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11470-choosing-an-ht-ft-65r-vs-baofeng-vs-d-stardmr-handhelds-plus-batteries-antennas-chirp-and-emergency-use/Share on other sites