EME by band: what 2 m, 70 cm, 23 cm and 10 GHz moonbounce really demand, and how JT65/Q65, Faraday and libration change the plan
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
Starting a thread to compare the bands side by side, since EME advice is usually scattered by band. The aim is to line up the physics with the hardware, and then argue about where the real thresholds sit. Corrections welcome, especially on current activity conventions, which vary and should always be checked against what active stations are doing.
The link budget. Round-trip path loss via the Moon is roughly 252 dB on 144 MHz, 261 dB on 432 MHz, 271 dB on 1296 MHz and around 290 dB on 10 GHz. It rises as 20 log f, and it swings about 2 dB between perigee and apogee. The key point is that antenna gain for a fixed physical aperture rises with frequency too, at both ends of the path. So higher bands do not demand proportionally more brute force. A 3 m dish gives roughly 29-30 dBi at 1296 MHz and close to 48 dBi at 10 GHz. What you pay in at the top end is pointing accuracy, tracking, feed and transmit-line losses, and wider Doppler spread.
Rough hardware by band. These are ballpark figures, not guarantees, since results depend on who you are trying to work.
On 2 m, the common approach is an array of long-boom Yagis (four is a typical starting array), a transmit chain in the high hundreds of watts up to the legal limit, very low-loss feedline, and a mast-mounted low-noise preamp. A single long Yagi plus power can hear and work the largest stations in digital modes. It is a limited, schedule-dependent path, but it shows that the entry barrier on 2 m is lower than people assume.
On 70 cm, Yagi arrays are still the usual route because a dish needs to be several metres across to match them at that wavelength. Expect more elements or more Yagis than on 2 m for similar performance. Sky noise is lower than on 2 m, so receive-chain quality counts for more.
On 23 cm, dishes dominate. A 3 m class dish with a good feed, circular polarisation and a few hundred watts at the feed is a recognised stepping stone. Beamwidth is around 5 degrees, so tracking becomes automatic rather than manual.
On 10 GHz, the Moon is only about 0.5 degrees across, and a 3 m dish has a beamwidth of well under a degree. Pointing accuracy, a rigid mount, a stable LO and frequency-calibrated gear matter as much as raw power. Moon and Sun noise measurements are the standard way to verify gain and pointing.
Modes. JT65 has long been the workhorse. JT65B is typical for 144/432 and JT65C for 1296 and up, where wider tone spacing copes with spread. Q65 is the newer WSJT-X mode, with submodes A to E that set the tone spacing for different spread. It generally decodes slightly better than JT65 under comparable conditions and supports averaging across periods. The WSJT-X guide has a recommended submode table, and active groups usually settle on one letter per band. Use the echo test and the Astronomical Data window (Moon azimuth and elevation, Doppler, delay, spread, degradation estimate) to confirm your own setup before you try for a QSO.
Questions to start: where do you think the practical break-even is for a first 70 cm station, Yagis or a dish? What fraction of lost QSOs on 2 m are really polarisation rather than raw signal? And how do you plan skeds when your moon window with the partner is short?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11473-eme-by-band-what-2-m-70-cm-23-cm-and-10-ghz-moonbounce-really-demand-and-how-jt65q65-faraday-and-libration-change-the-plan/Share on other sites