VHF/UHF antenna choices: when does each design actually make sense? (J-pole, slim jim, 5/8 whip, collinear, yagi)
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
Antenna threads often turn into "which one has the most gain," but the better question is what the antenna has to do. Let's compare the common VHF/UHF designs by job: base station, mobile, repeater access, weak-signal work, or satellites.
Quarter-wave whip. It is about 19 inches at 146 MHz and about 6.5 inches at 446 MHz. It is simple, mechanically tough, and tolerant of a mediocre ground plane. Its pattern is omnidirectional in azimuth with a fairly high takeoff angle. That is fine for local FM work, but it has no gain over a dipole. It needs a ground plane, such as a vehicle roof, to work as intended.
5/8 wave. On a decent ground plane, a 5/8-wave vertical gives roughly 3 dB over a quarter-wave. Its lower takeoff angle puts more energy toward the horizon. It needs a matching network, usually a coil at the base, and it depends more on ground-plane quality than a quarter-wave does. On a small or off-center ground plane the pattern can tilt upward and the gain advantage shrinks. Dual-band mobile whips combine different electrical lengths in one radiator, so their VHF and UHF behavior can differ.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave radiators with a quarter-wave matching section. The J-pole is a half-wave element with a shorted stub. The slim jim is a folded variation, usually built from ladder line or tubing. Both give roughly dipole-like gain, and the slim jim tends to have a slightly lower takeoff angle. They are cheap and easy to build. The weak point is common-mode current: with no ground plane, the coax shield can become part of the antenna, which distorts the pattern and shifts the SWR when you touch or move the feedline. A choke (ferrite or coiled coax) and a good feedpoint tap help.
Collinear. Stacked, phased half-wave sections narrow the elevation beam and raise gain, commonly 3 to 9 dBi depending on length. The tradeoff is a flatter pattern, so mounting height and mast verticality matter more. A tilted mast or a very high site relative to the users can leave nearby stations in the nulls. Collinears suit repeater sites and coverage over flat terrain, and they are less useful in hilly areas where signals arrive at varied angles.
Yagi. A yagi trades coverage for gain and front-to-back ratio. A three-element is often in the 6 to 8 dBi range, and gain grows with boom length. It is the usual choice for a known direction, such as one repeater or a weak-signal contact. Polarization matters: FM repeaters are almost always vertical, while SSB/CW weak-signal work on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally horizontal. Mixing polarizations can cost many dB in practice.
Feedline and connectors. Coax loss rises quickly with frequency, so a feedline that is fine at 2 m can eat your gain at 70 cm. Thin RG-58 loses several dB per 100 ft at VHF and roughly double that at UHF. LMR-400-class cable is about 1.5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and 2.7 dB at 450 MHz. PL-259/SO-239 connectors are acceptable at VHF but are not constant-impedance and are poor above about 300 MHz. N-type connectors are constant-impedance, sealed with an O-ring, and a better fit for UHF and outdoor runs. Waterproofing matters whichever type you use.
Mounting and SWR. NMO mounts need a 3/4-inch hole and give a solid, low-loss connection. Magnetic mounts couple to the roof partly capacitively, so a clean surface and a centered position help, and the coax lead can be damaged by pinching in a door. Remember that SWR is not efficiency: a dummy load shows 1:1 and radiates nothing, and lossy coax can make a bad antenna look better. Check SWR at the antenna when you can, across the whole band you use.
For repeaters, satellites, or a mobile install, what compromises are you working with, and which of these tradeoffs matters most for your setup?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11476-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-when-does-each-design-actually-make-sense-j-pole-slim-jim-58-whip-collinear-yagi/Share on other sites