Choosing an SDR chain for HF and VHF: dynamic range, upconverters, antennas and which software to pair with it
- Replies 2
- Views 27
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
This is a planning question about the whole receive chain, not only which dongle to buy. The goal is general-coverage listening from HF through VHF/UHF, plus decoding digital signals (FT8 and other WSJT-X modes, DMR/P25 where legal to monitor, ADS-B, AIS, weather satellites). Here is how the pieces seem to fit, and where I'd like corrections.
Hardware tiers, roughly. RTL-SDR dongles use an 8-bit RTL2832U ADC with about 2.4 MHz of reliably usable bandwidth. They are cheap and good for VHF/UHF, but they overload easily in the presence of strong broadcast signals. HackRF One is also 8-bit, but it covers 1 MHz to 6 GHz, with up to 20 MS/s and transmit capability (half duplex). SDRplay RSP-series receivers and the Airspy line (R2, Mini, HF+) use higher-resolution converters with better front-end filtering, and cost more. LimeSDR is a 12-bit transceiver with a very wide tuning range, aimed more at experimenters than at casual listening.
For HF, the options seem to be: (1) direct sampling on an RTL-SDR, (2) an upconverter in front of a dongle, or (3) a receiver that covers HF natively. I'd like to understand the trade-offs in practice, especially regarding noise and overload, and how people decide between a more expensive receiver and a cheaper one with external filtering.
On software: SDR# and HDSDR on Windows, SDRuno for SDRplay hardware, GQRX on Linux/macOS, CubicSDR as a cross-platform option. Which of these handle audio routing to decoders most cleanly, and what is the least painful way to run a panadapter or bandscope next to a conventional transceiver without risking the SDR during transmit?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11501-choosing-an-sdr-chain-for-hf-and-vhf-dynamic-range-upconverters-antennas-and-which-software-to-pair-with-it/Share on other sites