Run, S&P, or hop bands? How do you decide when a multiplier is worth the rate hit (and where SO2R fits)
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
Most contest operating advice boils down to "keep the rate up and pick up multipliers", but those two goals pull against each other constantly. I'd like to compare how people actually make the decision in the chair, so here is a framework to argue with.
Start with the marginal value of each contact. In a typical QSO-points-times-multipliers contest, score = points × mults. One more QSO adds roughly (average points per QSO × current mults). One more new multiplier adds roughly (total QSO points so far). If every QSO is worth 1 point, a new mult is worth about Q/M contacts. With 1,000 QSOs and 100 mults, a new mult equals about 10 contacts. With 300 QSOs and 60 mults, it equals about 5. Early in a contest the QSO count is small, so mults are cheap to ignore. Later the mult is worth chasing, but only if you can get it in less time than it would take to make that many QSOs at your current rate. If your run rate is 120/hr, 10 QSOs is five minutes. A 30-second tune, call and exchange is a bargain. A 10-minute pileup fight for a rare one is not.
That is the core of search-and-pounce versus running. Running at a steady rate usually beats S&P on raw QSOs per hour, because you don't spend time tuning, listening and waiting for the other station to finish. S&P is how you collect mults that never come to you, and it is often the better choice when the run frequency is dead, when the band is closing, or when you have no clean frequency. The cleanest compromise is to run until the rate falls below a threshold, then do a short S&P sweep through the band map for needed mults, then go back to CQing. N1MM Logger+'s rate display, the available-mults/Qs window and the band map make that threshold easy to watch. What do you use as a trigger? A fixed number like 60/hr, a drop against your last 10-minute rate, or just a gut feeling?
Band changes have their own cost. Each one means a few seconds to retune and re-establish a run frequency, then a ramp-up while people find you. The usual logic is to change when the next band is better, not because the current one has "gone quiet" for a few minutes. Look at your 10- and 60-minute rate by band, check the band map, and think about propagation timing: grayline openings, the 15/10 meter closing in the afternoon, and the low bands opening toward dusk. Many people use the first 10-20 minutes after a band change as a diagnostic. If the rate doesn't come up, they go back or try another band.
SO2R changes the arithmetic. With two radios and a way to switch audio and keying, you can run on one radio while the second searches for mults. The second radio only needs a few seconds to snag one, and you only lose rate if the second radio takes your attention away from the run. SO2R is not free, though. It needs a hardware interface or a supported switch, band-pass filters or stubs to limit the interference between radios, good headphone audio (many operators use stereo split so each radio goes to one ear), and some thought about antenna separation and band pairings. Adjacent bands, or a harmonic pair like 40 and 20, are harder than 20 and 80. There is also a human limit. The extra radio is only helpful if you can manage it without sloppy copy and logging errors.
On the data side, spots are a big lever. A skimmer or packet/RBN spots can show where the mults are without tuning. Remember the rules: in many contests, using spotting information from outside your own station puts you in an Assisted class, while Unassisted categories restrict that. Check the rules for each contest, including how they treat local decoders, before deciding what to have running. Assisted vs. Unassisted, power level (high, low, QRP), single band vs. all band, and the contest's treatment of two radios can all change your best strategy. For example, with spots available you can spend more of your time running, because mults can be targeted exactly when you want them.
Finally, there are antennas and endurance. Gain is nice, but being able to switch quickly between a stack, a single higher Yagi, and a low-angle option may matter more than a few dB of gain on one band. On 160/80/40, a good receive antenna (Beverage, loop or other low-noise option) often helps more than extra power. And in a 24- or 48-hour contest, rate over the whole event depends on staying sharp. Hydration, food, planned breaks and when you take your off time are all strategy. A popular method is to look at the rate sheet and put your off time where your rate normally drops anyway, rather than guessing.
Questions for the thread: How do you set your S&P trigger? What is your rule for leaving a band that is still giving moderate rate? If you use SO2R, which band pairings work, and which fail because of interference? And how do you plan breaks so you don't lose a prime opening?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11506-run-sp-or-hop-bands-how-do-you-decide-when-a-multiplier-is-worth-the-rate-hit-and-where-so2r-fits/Share on other sites